Locals account for under 20% of visits to new grocery stores in food deserts
A Binghamton University and UConn study of 112 neighborhoods found that local low-income residents made fewer than 20% of visits to new grocery stores in food deserts. Price and habit appear to matter more than distance. Grocers siting stores there should forecast local trade separately and build affordability tools into the plan.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Retail teams put it to work with Sales Enablement.
Key takeaways
When fewer than one in five visits to a new food-desert store come from the neighborhood it was built for, the distance problem may be solved while other barriers still limit local use.
Opening-month traffic is a poor baseline for a new store in a low-income area: visits peak in the first month, fall, then level off.
Loyalty programs reach low-income shoppers less often: where programs exist, 58% of households earning under $35,000 are members vs. 78% of those earning $150,000+. For a store opening in a LILA area, sign-ups at the door could help close that gap.
Free workspace
Turn your Retail expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
Fewer than one in five visits to new grocery stores in U.S. food deserts come from the low-income neighborhoods those stores were supposed to serve.
That is the central result of a study covering the whole country, carried out by researchers from Binghamton University and the University of Connecticut. It was published in Applied Geography, and Binghamton's news office announced it on Nov. 18 in a story by Jennifer Micale. Flip the number and the point becomes clearer. Simple arithmetic shows that people living outside the food desert made up more than 80% of the traffic.
The traffic curve has its own lesson. Visits peaked in the first month, fell off, then leveled out. Anyone who has judged a new location by its grand-opening weeks knows the shape. What's new is the detail underneath it: over the whole period, the neighbors made up a small minority of the people coming through the doors.
The result matters to a specific group of people. That includes grocers weighing a store in an underserved area, the developers and lenders who finance those projects, and anyone running incentive programs built on a string of government efforts, the 2014 Farm Bill among them, to encourage grocery openings in these neighborhoods. A new store solves the distance problem. The study suggests distance was rarely what kept residents away.
How the researchers tracked the trips
The team paired 112 low-income, low-access areas that got a new grocery store with 336 similar areas that did not. That works out to three comparison areas for each area with a new store. They then compared residents' grocery trips before and after each opening in both groups. Because of that design, a change in shopping can be credited to the new store and not to wider shifts that hit every neighborhood at once.
The under-20% local share is an average across those stores. It describes the pattern over the 112 areas, not the result at any single opening, which is why it works best as a benchmark for comparison.
Earlier work on these policies was mostly regional and smaller in scale. The Binghamton announcement describes this as the first study to use large-scale human mobility data to judge the policy's effect nationwide. That method fits the team. Miao said her research since her PhD program has focused on spatial data science and geospatial computational methods, applied to urban transportation, human mobility, spatial accessibility and health disparity.
The authors are Congcong Miao, an assistant professor of geography who joined Binghamton this fall; Xiang Chen, an associate professor of geography, sustainability, community and urban studies at UConn; and Ran Xu, a UConn associate professor of allied health sciences and a public health biostatistician. The paper is peer-reviewed and was released online ahead of print in the journal's October 2026 listing, according to the Newswise version of the release, whose citation links to the article on ScienceDirect.
LILA stands for low-income, low-access. It is the U.S. Department of Agriculture's term for what most people call a food desert: a low-income neighborhood where healthy, affordable food is hard to reach. A quasi-experimental design builds treatment and comparison groups from existing data after the fact, instead of assigning stores at random.
Price and habit outrank distance
Xu described the usual way of thinking: a food desert is a low-income area missing a grocery store, so the fix is to add one. The data didn't support that.
Even if you add a grocery store, people don't go there for various reasons., Ran Xu, associate professor of allied health sciences, UConn
Chen said the barrier isn't only about geography. For some households, cost is still the obstacle. Others keep using the food sources they already have, convenience stores included, out of habit or cultural preference.
A different access fix has run into a similar wall. A 2022 study in the journal Appetite surveyed 310 SNAP-eligible Maryland households with young children after a federal policy allowed SNAP benefits to be used for online grocery purchases. Families reported buying fresh produce, and meat and seafood, less often online than in store. Online food selection and fees were common obstacles, and families described mistrust of hired online shoppers. Delivery takes the trip out of the picture entirely, and the cost and trust problems were still there.
Current price data shows how strong that cost barrier is right now. At a Nov. 12 briefing hosted by FMI, The Food Industry Association and covered by The Shelby Report, Cal Poly agribusiness professor Ricky Volpe said food prices rose 0.4% in the latest Consumer Price Index release, ending three straight reports of roughly flat prices. Repeated every month, he noted, an increase that size would add up to nearly 5 percentage points over a year, against the 2% to 2.5% the food-at-home index typically climbs annually.
He linked the rise to energy costs and said he expects retail food inflation to stay somewhat elevated into early 2027. Among the steepest increases he listed were lettuce, tomatoes, bell peppers and some citrus fruits, pushed up by energy costs and by weather disruptions in the Southeast, western Mexico and Southern California. Those are the fresh items food-access policy is meant to put within reach.
FMI's own shopper research, presented at the same briefing by Steve Markenson, the association's vice president of research and insights, shows how stretched shoppers feel. It also shows how carefully they plan: 72% say they are doing OK as long as they stick to their budget. A new store has to fit inside a budget like that, not just on the route home.
How grocery shoppers are coping with prices
FMI U.S. Grocery Shopper Trends, as reported by The Shelby Report
Put that next to the Binghamton finding and the explanation hangs together. Shoppers already spread their trips across several stores and send most of their money to one main store, which means a new store isn't stepping into empty space. It has to win trips away from habits that are already set. A shorter drive doesn't lower the total at the register.
When fewer than one in five visits to a new food-desert store come from the neighborhood it was built for, the map has changed and the grocery bill has not.
Where price-led stores and loyalty programs fit
Grocers are already building formats aimed at the price barrier, though none of the recent ones is pitched as a food-desert project. Grocery Dive's Sam Silverstein reported on Nov. 18 that Cosentino's Food Stores opened ChopMore! in Kansas City, Missouri, a no-frills store that sells groceries at cost plus a flat 10% markup to cover overhead. Cosentino's fleet already includes discount Price Chopper stores, and ChopMore! leans harder on price than those. Houchens Food Group launched Food Saver, three stores in Georgia and Tennessee with a focus on fresh meat and produce.
The Save Mart Companies reopened its smaller Maxx Value store in Modesto, California, late last year, with a "Wall of Value" of low-priced pallets. Dunnhumby's latest Consumer Trends Tracker found that more than a third of U.S. shoppers have skipped a meal or eaten less to save money.
The people Grocery Dive interviewed warned that low prices alone aren't enough, particularly with Walmart and Aldi holding a commanding position in grocery. Erich Kahner, Dunnhumby's head of strategy and insights for North America, said the firm's data show shoppers believe both have improved their assortments and shopping experiences while keeping their price edge. For any new store, including one in a LILA area, that is the competition its price promise would be measured against.
Tom Furphy, CEO of Consumer Equity Partners and a former Wegmans executive, was blunt: "You can't just slap a low price image on something and expect that it's just going to work." A low-price image, he said, only works if the cost structure behind it can last and shoppers can clearly see how the format differs from the chain's regular stores. Kahner said shoppers reward stores that make feeding a family affordable without asking them to give up much on taste or nutrition. That second point lines up with what the food-access researchers care about.
Loyalty programs are the other tool, and they have a gap that matters here. The FMI data shows that where a program exists, 58% of shoppers earning under $35,000 a year are members, compared with 78% of those earning $150,000 or more. About 60% of grocers run a program. Andy Harig, FMI's vice president of tax, trade, sustainability and policy development, called loyalty programs "one of the most direct ways grocers are meeting shoppers where they live," and pointed out that the households with the most to gain are the least likely to be enrolled.
The programs themselves don't seem to be the hard sell. FMI found that 89% of shoppers know about the program at their primary store, about 7 in 10 of those offered one have joined, and about 3 in 4 members rate it extremely or highly valuable. That suggests enrollment is where lower-income households fall away. For a grocer opening in a LILA area, signing people up at the door could matter as much as the shelf price.
Private brands give that store another way to offer lower prices. Markenson estimated they have grown to about 25% of grocery sales from roughly 15% to 16% a decade ago, and described them as a tool FMI members use to offer better prices and options beyond national brands.
Before approving a store in a low-access area, have the site model split projected visits by where shoppers live. If the forecast counts on neighbors as the core customers, test it against the study's average of under 20%.
Visits are not baskets
The study's strongest caveat comes from its own method. It counts trips, not spending or what went into the cart, so it can't say whether the locals who did shop there bought more produce than before. A store that draws most of its shoppers from a wider area can also be a perfectly good business. The finding speaks to the food-access goal, not to whether the store makes money.
The authors reach a similar conclusion. Miao said new stores may do more good as one piece of a wider strategy, and that they can benefit a neighborhood in ways that go beyond food access. In her view, adding more grocery stores will not on its own improve access to food. It also takes an understanding of what residents need and prefer and how they shop day to day, she said, as well as teaching people what makes up a healthy diet and lowering the cost of healthy food.
Chen suggested public money could do more if it went after obstacles like high food prices. Once it is clear the stores have no such effect, he said, the federal government could consider shifting its investment to the structural barriers that limit food access, with high food prices as one example.
The figure to ask for at the next opening
For a grocer or lender looking at a low-income, low-access neighborhood, this study gives a benchmark that didn't exist at national scale before. First-month traffic will flatter any new store. A better question is how many of the store's regular shoppers live in the neighborhood it was meant to serve. The next useful result would be a price-led format, cost-plus pricing like ChopMore!'s or a store opened alongside heavy loyalty sign-ups, that is placed inside a LILA area and measured the same way. Whether that pushes the local share above 20% is the number that would show which combination works.
Sources
- Opening new grocery stores doesn’t increase food access in low-income areas, nationwide study shows ↗
- Opening New Grocery Stores Doesn't Increase Food Access in Low- ... ↗
- Why grocers are opening new price-focused stores ↗ · Grocery Dive
- Food Prices Tick Higher As Shoppers Protect Holiday Meal ... ↗ · The Shelby Report
Featured companies
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Retail starts with a company putting its merchandising leads, store operations teams, and category managers on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Category buyers trust operators, so your merchandising leads shorten the distance between first search and first call.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.