Sterile processing deviations become the norm without stop-and-document rules
Advanced Sterilization Products' Tamara Beeler told Censis Technologies' CtUC 2026 audience that sterile processing deviations harden into norms when departments don’t stop, escalate and document them. She connects ANSI/AAMI ST108:2023 water categories, daily cleaning verification, loaner-tray refusal when sets arrive late or lack IFUs, and root cause analysis when rework repeats on the same device.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Healthcare teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.
Key takeaways
ANSI/AAMI ST108:2023 turned water quality for instrument reprocessing into an enforceable standard; AAMI's earlier TIR34 was guidance with no enforcement behind it.
Some facilities require loaner trays 48 hours before a case, and ASP's Tamara Beeler says a technician at any level can refuse one that arrives late, undocumented or dirty.
Rework that returns on the same device is the point at which Beeler wants a root cause analysis opened, with the record kept in the instrument tracking system.
Free workspace
Turn your Healthcare expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
Brown water running from a decontamination sink is the first gray area Tamara Beeler asked her audience to picture. Speaking in a recorded session on day two of CtUC 2026, the virtual user conference Censis Technologies held in September 2026, the Advanced Sterilization Products (ASP) presenter described construction near a hospital, dirt in the supply line and a department that has to decide whether the instruments it is washing are getting clean at all.
So at what point do we stop, pause, do a timeout, and say, my water is not where it needs to be. — Tamara Beeler, MSN, RN, Advanced Sterilization Products (ASP)
The timing matters because the documents behind that decision changed. ANSI/AAMI ST108:2023, published in 2023, made water quality for device reprocessing a standard rather than a technical report, and in July 2026 the AORN Journal published a peer-reviewed review of loaner instrument sets that lists inconsistent arrival timing and incomplete manufacturer instructions for use among the systemic risks to sterile processing departments. Beeler's session pulls those threads into one argument: when equipment, documentation or staffing fall short of the instructions for use, the department stops, escalates and writes it down, because the alternative is a workaround that has quietly become the rule.
An IFU, the manufacturer's instructions for use, is the validated procedure for cleaning, inspecting, packaging and sterilizing a specific device, and sterile processing departments (SPDs) are held to it by accreditation surveyors. AAMI, the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation, writes the consensus standards those surveyors read alongside the IFU. Beeler's point is that neither document tells a technician what to do on the morning the washer is down.
Brown water is a stop signal, and ST108 made the water rules enforceable
ANSI/AAMI ST108:2023 sorts reprocessing water into three categories: utility water, critical water and steam. According to ANSI's explainer on the 2023 standard, utility water comes from the tap, may need treatment at the facility, and serves flushing, washing and the rinse between cleaning and disinfection. Critical water has been through a multi-step treatment, usually reverse osmosis or deionization, and is reserved for the final rinse and for generating steam, which the standard treats as its own category whether it comes from a central boiler or a generator beside the sterilizer.
The reason the categories matter is biology that treatment does not fully fix. ANSI notes that gram-negative bacteria and nontuberculous mycobacteria can grow in water regardless of how it was treated, which is why the standard asks for ongoing monitoring rather than a one-time qualification. Poor water, by ANSI's account, stains, pits and corrodes instruments and can block lumens, and on the patient side Beeler listed infection, toxicity and pyrogenic reactions, the fevers triggered by bacterial fragments left on a device.
FACS says in its own guide to the standard that ST108:2023 replaced the earlier AAMI TIR34:2017 and expects each facility to form a water management team drawn from infection control, facilities, engineering and biomedical staff. The same guide says a newly installed treatment system gets a performance qualification with daily sampling at critical points, after which routine testing settles into a cadence FACS describes as daily conductivity or pH checks for critical water and quarterly hardness checks for utility water. The numeric limits for each category sit in the purchased standard, which AAMI sells through the ANSI webstore, while the public summaries describe the categories and the cadence.
That shift from report to standard is the complication in Beeler's framing of the water rules as something the field has followed for years. Chris Sullivan of IWC Innovations, a water treatment vendor, wrote in a July 2024 post on the company's site that a technical information report such as TIR34 offers guidance and best practice but is not enforceable, while a standard is what regulators and accreditation bodies check compliance against. For an SPD manager that closes the gray area Beeler opened with: a brown faucet is no longer a judgment call, because the standard now expects a team, a monitoring record and a documented response.
A down washer sends every tray back to manual cleaning at the IFU's dwell time
Beeler's second scenario is the automated washer that goes down on a weekday morning. The options she listed are manual cleaning, a sister facility or an off-site reprocessor, and each one has to meet the same IFU the washer was validated against. Manual cleaning is where she sees the corner get cut.
The mechanism is chemistry with a clock on it. The enzymes in an enzymatic detergent act as catalysts that begin breaking down blood and tissue, and they need the water temperature and the full exposure time the IFU specifies before they do any useful work, so a device dipped and pulled early leaves the bioburden largely intact. Rinsing then has to be thorough, Beeler said, so that detergent residue does not react with the chemistry of the next step.
Inspection has its own exception. The current AAMI language says devices should be inspected visually, preferably with lighted magnification, and Beeler told the audience that 'preferably' in a standard means it should be done. She has walked through departments where one lighted station serves several technicians and others where every station has its own light, and the second layout is the one that lets a technician see residual soil and damage the eye misses.
Cleaning verification is the check Beeler tied directly to AAMI's text. Verification kits, the chemical or protein tests that confirm a washer or an instrument is actually clean, should be run at minimum every day and more often when a washer shows a high malfunction rate. A device that fails goes back through decontamination from the start, and the find, the return and the outcome belong in the instrument tracking system so the department can show an audit trail later.
When the IFU asks for equipment the department does not own, an ultrasonic cycle for instance, Beeler's instruction is the same as for the water. Stop, notify the supervisor and do not use the device until the facility can follow the manufacturer's steps. She also asked departments to confirm they can retrieve the IFU for low-volume, high-risk devices, the ones a technician may see twice a year.
A late loaner tray can be refused, and the AORN Journal calls late arrival systemic
Loaner trays, instrument sets a vendor brings in for a specific case, drew the most personal account of the session. Beeler described standing on the decontamination side of a department during a training visit and watching a set arrive with a demand that it be processed immediately, an exchange she called inappropriate for the technician and uncomfortable to witness as a fellow vendor. The pattern she sees behind it is a sales representative promising a surgeon a device for the next day, outside the window the facility requires.
And I hope that you feel empowered no matter what level you are at a facility to say, I cannot accept this tray. This is not appropriate. — Tamara Beeler, MSN, RN, Advanced Sterilization Products (ASP)
Infection Control Today reported in April 2018 that some facilities require loaner trays 48 hours before the scheduled case. That figure gives scale to Beeler's complaint: a tray promised the evening before has lost most of that window before it reaches the dock. The same report said that when the surgical schedule leaves no time to sterilize a loaner between cases, departments fall back on immediate-use steam sterilization (IUSS), an abbreviated cycle with no drying or storage, and that many loaner instruments have never been validated for it.
The 2018 report also reproduced a remark from a 2012 source by Rose Seavey, a consultant and former sterile processing director, that the concern is usually the enormous number of trays a department receives and the lack of time it is given to reprocess them properly, and the report added that understaffed personnel may cut corners and omit processing steps. It cited a 2015 analysis in which pieces of bone were found inside a reamer because staff did not know how to connect its components, and in which debris arrived in loaner sets labeled sterile. Beeler's three grounds for refusal, late delivery, a missing IFU on an unfamiliar device, and visible gross contamination from another facility, map onto exactly those failures.
The AORN Journal review published in July 2026 complicates the picture by treating late arrival as a system design problem rather than a behavior problem. Its authors, Brian Shea, Matthew Avilla and Rebecca Alvino, list inconsistent arrival timing, incomplete IFUs, complex and unfamiliar instruments, inventory and scheduling conflicts, communication gaps among sterile processing, operating room personnel and vendors, and difficulties returning sets after cases, and they recommend written policies for arrival and processing timelines, digital inventory management, education and standardized communication protocols. Beeler does not disagree; her refusal protocol is the enforcement end of the policy the AORN authors want written down. Neither the review nor Beeler puts a number on how often a tray arrives inside the window.
Off-site reprocessing puts the van and the driver under DOT's infectious substance rules
Off-site reprocessing, where a facility ships soiled instruments to a central plant and receives them back sterile, moves the gray area onto a loading dock and into a van. Beeler's questions for that arrangement are blunt: is the vehicle divided so dirty devices never ride with clean ones, are the containers secured against tipping and bouncing, is the vehicle decontaminated between loads, and have the drivers been trained on the difference. Those answers belong to the manager, the director and the environment of care staff, she said, but the department owns the process because its devices are the cargo.
Under 49 CFR 173.134, an infectious substance is any material known or reasonably expected to contain a pathogen. The regulation, part of the Department of Transportation's hazardous materials rules in the current Code of Federal Regulations text published by Cornell Law School's Legal Information Institute, assigns such material to Division 6.2 and splits it into Category A, forms capable of causing permanent disability or life-threatening disease, shipped under identification numbers UN2814, UN2900 or UN3549, and Category B, everything else, shipped as 'Biological substance, Category B' under UN3373. Regulated medical waste carries its own number, UN3291, and the text makes the category assignment depend on the source patient's known medical history, local conditions or professional judgment.
The practical reading for an SPD leader is that a cart of used instruments with dried blood on it is material reasonably expected to contain a pathogen, and the shipping decision is a classification decision somebody has to document. Beeler extended the same logic to the robotic delivery carts she has seen in facilities, which carry clean trays from sterile processing to the operating room and dirty ones back. If the same robot runs both directions, someone has to clean it in between and record that they did.
The dock is where she sees the earliest version of the problem. External shipping boxes come off before anything enters the department, biohazard containers waiting for pickup never share dock space with incoming clean trays, and the IFU travels with the item rather than taped to a box headed for the compactor.
IFU contradictions trace back to FDA review, and APIC and HSPA are taking that up
Beeler fields calls from technicians who cannot find an IFU, sends the current version, and learns the department had been working from an outdated one. She called contradictory and unreadable IFUs the big elephant in the room, and then offered an explanation the audience may not have heard before.
Her account is that infection prevention professionals at APIC, the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology, and the sterile processing membership of HSPA, the Healthcare Sterile Processing Association, are partnering with industry to make that case to the FDA. She described the realization that manufacturers were not padding IFUs voluntarily as an eye opener for the infection prevention side, and said the work is under way without giving a timeline or a deliverable. Infection Control Today's 2018 report pointed at one concrete example of the mismatch: IFUs that list sterilization temperatures never validated for use in the United States, which leave personnel calling the manufacturer to resolve the conflict.
Until that work produces something a surveyor will accept, the department carries the contradiction. Beeler's interim practice is procedural: confirm the IFU on hand is the current revision, check whether new AAMI annexes and technical information reports are reaching the department as they publish, and treat any IFU step the facility cannot perform as a stop rather than a skip.
Repeat rework on one device is the trigger for a root cause analysis
Rework that comes back on the same device is Beeler's trigger for a root cause analysis. A single tray returned to decontamination has an ordinary explanation: a technician in a hurry, a new hire, an unfamiliar device. The same tray returned repeatedly means the process is producing the failure, and a root cause analysis, a structured review that traces a failure back to the condition that allowed it, is how the department finds the condition instead of fixing the symptom again.
Beeler said she would share a root cause analysis form published by CMS, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, that she finds useful for this step; the form itself does not appear in the recorded portion of the session. What the session does supply is the input: the rework record in the tracking system, the reason coded for each return, and the damage noted before the device goes back through decontamination.
The ultrasonic cleaner is where she expects the next wave of exceptions, because the robotic instrument lines facilities keep adding require it. Cavitation, the collapse of microscopic bubbles that sound waves create in the bath, scrubs crevices a brush cannot reach, but the aerosol it throws carries the bioburden off the device, so the lid stays closed. Her checklist for the unit is to run only devices whose IFU calls for ultrasonic cleaning and only after manual cleaning, to clean the unit every day, to run a daily cavitation test, to degas the solution when the IFU asks, and to settle which shift owns and documents that work in a three-shift department.
Staffing is the exception that sits under all the others. Beeler asked whether a short-staffed department will skip steps or go faster, and listed what follows when it does: missed point-of-use treatment, missed inspections, lumens flushed inadequately and damaged instruments left in trays because no replacement exists. Her example was a pair of dull scissors that will eventually cut, which she would not want used on her, and the consequences she named run from patient harm through regulatory scrutiny, loss of accreditation and lost reimbursement.
For a sterile processing leader, Beeler's session reduces to a short list of stops with paperwork attached. Confirm the IFU is current and retrievable for the devices seen least often, run and record cleaning verification daily, write the loaner refusal rule down and back the technician who uses it, put the transport questions to whoever manages the off-site contract, and open a root cause analysis the second time a device comes back. The signal Beeler points to is rework returning on the same device, because that is the deviation about to be accepted as normal.
Sources
- ANSI/AAMI ST108:2023, Water for Processing Medical Devices ↗ · ANSI
- Addressing Challenges Associated With Loaner Instrument Sets ↗ · AORN Journal (via NIH/PMC)
- 49 CFR § 173.134 - Definitions and exceptions ↗ · Cornell Law School (Legal Information Institute)
- What is the Difference Between ST108 and TIR34? ↗ · IWC Innovations
- The Challenges Associated with Loaner Instrumentation ↗ · Infection Control Today
Featured companies
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Healthcare starts with a company putting its clinicians, service-line leaders, and field engineers on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Service-line buyers vet vendors quietly, and your clinicians become the proof they find while doing it.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.