Why hospitals stagger security upgrades instead of shutting down
Parabit Systems' Robert Iraggi told A Weekly Bit that hospital security upgrades must be planned and staggered because the building never closes. OSHA counted 7.8 serious violent injuries per 10,000 healthcare workers in 2013 against under two in construction, and Joint Commission EP 17 requires an annual worksite analysis. Illinois biometric law adds a consent step for facial recognition.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Healthcare teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.
Key takeaways
OSHA counted 7.8 serious violent injuries per 10,000 healthcare workers in 2013; construction, manufacturing and retail each stayed under two.
Joint Commission EP 17 has required an annual workplace violence worksite analysis since January 2022, and hospitals are expected to act on what it finds—making phased security upgrades easier to document year to year.
Squire Patton Boggs counted at least 100 Illinois biometric privacy class actions filed in 2025, and Illinois’ BIPA requires notice and consent for collecting biometrics—so a facial-recognition rollout plan should include the notice, consent record, and retention controls before the first camera goes live.
Free workspace
Turn your Healthcare expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
Robert Iraggi gave the honest answer first. Asked on Episode 84 of A Weekly Bit how a property owner upgrades access control, the readers, locks and credentials that decide who can open which door, without disrupting anyone, Parabit Systems' Iraggi said the work disrupts.
Then host Ben Thomas moved to the building that never closes. A hospital runs around the clock with shifts coming on and off, a wing closed for work here and a cafeteria being updated there, and the patients stay. In a MarketScale Studio segment recorded for the series, Iraggi's answer for that setting was to plan the upgrade and stagger it.
The money behind the question is now public. In a June 2025 report commissioned by the American Hospital Association and conducted by the University of Washington's Harborview Injury Prevention and Research Center, workplace and community violence was estimated to have cost U.S. hospitals $18.27 billion in 2023. The report split that into $3.62 billion spent before incidents on training, security staffing, facility modifications and monitoring technology, and $14.65 billion after them, the largest share being medical care for violent injuries; prevention is about a fifth of the total, arithmetic on the report's figures.
The rule changed in the same window. JMG Security Systems, a security integrator, wrote in a 2026 post on its own site that Joint Commission standard NPG.02.04.01 took effect in January 2026 and requires accredited hospitals to maintain a workplace violence prevention program covering leadership, policies, reporting, training, an annual worksite analysis and action on what it finds. A hospital security director asking for a phased upgrade budget in 2026 has a dated obligation and a dollar figure to point to.
Healthcare's violence rate is four times private industry's
Thomas framed healthcare on the episode as among the places where workplace and domestic violence runs highest, which makes the upgrade a matter of employee security and patient security alike. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration's own count, published in a December 2015 bulletin, backs that framing. OSHA counted 7.8 serious violent injuries per 10,000 healthcare workers in 2013; construction, manufacturing and retail stayed under two.
Serious, in OSHA's definition, means the injured worker needed days off to recover. By that measure the bulletin found such incidents four times as common in healthcare as in private industry on average from 2002 to 2013, and traced 80 percent of the 2013 incidents to interactions with patients, with visitors, coworkers and others accounting for the rest. OSHA listed a domestic dispute that spills into the workplace among the typical scenarios, alongside gang violence in the emergency department and a distraught family member who turns abusive.
The environmental causes OSHA named read like a punch list for the upgrade Iraggi describes: unrestricted public access, poor lighting in hallways and outside, design that blocks vision or escape routes, no means of emergency communication, long waits in overcrowded waiting rooms and understaffing at meal times and visiting hours. Each item maps to a door, a camera, a sensor or a duress button, the staff-triggered alarm, in a security plan.
EP 17 turns a security upgrade into an annual obligation
Joint Commission EP 17 has required an annual violence worksite analysis at accredited hospitals since January 2022. An element of performance, or EP, is the specific action a surveyor checks under a broader standard; this one sits under standard EC.02.01.01, which requires the hospital to manage its safety and security risks, according to the June 2021 R3 Report. The hospital runs the analysis each year and then acts to mitigate or resolve the risks it turns up.
The commission defines the analysis in three parts: a proactive review of the worksite, an investigation of the hospital's own violence incidents, and a check of whether policies, training and environmental design match current best practice and applicable law. Its accreditation glossary defines workplace violence broadly, from verbal, written or physical aggression and threats through bullying, harassment and assault, involving staff, licensed practitioners, patients or visitors. The analysis therefore has to account for threats and harassment as well as physical assault.
The commission's stated rationale is that environmental modifications follow from what the analysis finds, and that because best practice and law keep changing, the program's policies and training are reviewed against them. A hospital that fixes everything in one closure has little new to show the surveyor the following year. A hospital that upgrades in planned stages has a documented program that moves with each annual finding.
The standard's reference list points hospitals to OSHA publication 3148, the 2016 guidelines for preventing workplace violence in healthcare and social service settings, and to the International Association for Healthcare Security and Safety, or IAHSS, for threat assessment practice. Dan Yaross, director of protective services at a pediatric hospital in Ohio, told ASIS International's Security Management magazine in a November 2022 interview that his hospital obtained a variance from the fire code so it could secure both sides of its inpatient units, then designated four security-sensitive areas in its security management plan based on Joint Commission requirements and IAHSS guidelines. His auditing department had wanted almost the whole hospital treated as security-sensitive; he limited very restrictive access control to those four areas and audits who holds access to each.
Zone by zone, with the failover written before the cutover
Iraggi's own prescription on the episode is short.
The first thing requires planning. — Robert Iraggi, Parabit Systems
JMG Security Systems says a hospital upgrade phases installation zone by zone with failover written before each cutover. The integrator's method starts earlier, mapping clinical movement and risk ahead of the floor plan, and ends later, with every alarm connected to a named response owner. Failover means what a door does when power, the network, the credential server or communications fail; cutover is the moment the new control replaces the old one; an override is the procedure that lets staff open a controlled door in an emergency.
The post sorts the building into zones with different jobs. Public entrances get visitor workflow, visible coverage and duress response; clinical corridors get role-based access and door status monitoring against tailgating, which is following a badge holder through a door; pharmacies and server rooms get stronger credentials, audit trails and video linked to each event; parking and loading areas get lighting, intercoms and perimeter monitoring. JMG wants security, facilities, IT, clinical leadership, emergency management and privacy or compliance staff in the same room from day one, because a control that looks airtight on a floor plan can create a dangerous delay or an unsafe workaround on a unit.
Before any control is approved, JMG runs it through five questions: whether it delays clinicians, patients or responders; whether it preserves safe egress, the exit path in an emergency; what happens during a power, network, server or credential failure; who receives the alert and verifies it; and what records it creates, who can see them and how long they are kept. An unclear answer to any of the five, the post says, means the design is not ready. The test is applied door by door and camera by camera, not once at the project level.
Tighter is not the goal, and the practitioners say so. William Marcisz, president and chief consultant of Strategic Security Management Consulting and a former hospital security administrator, told Security Management in November 2022 that department heads often want access control that resembles the Pentagon, but in a hospital with 5,000 employees the food service tray passers, phlebotomists and environmental services staff all need to get into the units those administrators want sealed. His counsel is open access for employees across most of the building and tight control only where it is absolutely needed, with a dedicated gatekeeper for any department that insists on a lockdown so care is not delayed.
That bounds the thesis without contradicting it. The stagger decides the order of the work; Marcisz's point is that it should also decide where the hospital stops adding restriction, and JMG's clinical-movement question is the test. No published benchmark sets a price or a month count for a phased hospital rollout, so a security director budgets from the zone map and the door count rather than from a trade figure.
Mobile credentials ride on the readers already in the wall
Security Control Integrators says a hardware add-on or software update lets an existing card reader accept a phone credential. A mobile credential is the badge moved onto the employee's smartphone, and Thomas raised it on the episode as one of the upgrades an owner asks for. In a February 2022 post on its own site, the integrator explained that the phone and the reader talk over Bluetooth Low Energy, Near Field Communication, which is a tap-range radio, or ultra-wideband, another short-range radio, and that minimal hardware makes an existing reader mobile-ready.
For a hospital, that is the point: readers convert in stages while the badge system keeps working. Security Control Integrators argues in the same post that a phone is lost or lent far less often than a card, that mobile credentials cannot be cloned the way plastic cards can, and that the system can demand a face or thumbprint check on the phone before a door opens. Permissions are granted and revoked remotely, and the firm says badges, photo IDs and credentials can be managed in the cloud without an on-site server, so a departing employee's access ends without anyone collecting a card.
The post names hospitals among the organizations that have implemented mobile credentials and says a hospital can use separate credential technologies for sensitive areas or restricted wards such as a maternity ward or secure supply closets. That tiered design matches Yaross's four security-sensitive zones and Marcisz's advice to lock down only what needs it. Parabit says on its own site that it builds the mounts, pedestals and enclosures that hold biometric readers and mobile credential devices at the door, so the hardware side of a staged conversion is a mounting job as much as a software one, and the sequence is JMG's: convert one zone's readers, confirm the failover, move to the next.
Facial recognition meets a $1,000-per-violation Illinois law
Squire Patton Boggs counted at least 100 Illinois biometric privacy class actions filed in 2025. Facial recognition, software that matches a camera image of a face against a stored identity, is the layer Iraggi named on the episode alongside credentials for knowing who needs to be where, and Parabit says on its own site that its camera housings are built to improve facial image capture for AI analytics and biometrics. The law firm's count, in a December 2025 review on its Privacy World blog, is the reason that layer belongs in the rollout plan rather than after it.
Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act, or BIPA, enacted in 2008, requires a private entity to give specific notice and obtain consent from the person whose face geometry, fingerprint or voiceprint it collects, according to the review. The law lets the individual sue directly, with statutory damages of $1,000 per negligent violation and $5,000 per willful or reckless one, and no need to prove actual harm. A 2024 amendment limited an aggrieved person to one recovery per company for repeated use of the same biometric, the firm noted, which capped the exposure without removing it.
The settlements show the scale. The review listed a nationwide settlement approved in May 2025 against a facial recognition company worth roughly $51.75 million, a $47.5 million settlement approved in September 2025 for a class of at least 150,000 people whose images were processed by facial recognition, and an $8.75 million settlement approved in October 2025 over face and voice models of about 660,000 Illinois students. Squire Patton Boggs also described mass arbitration, in which plaintiffs' firms file thousands of near-identical BIPA claims to run up a company's arbitration fees, as a staple of 2025 filings.
Neither the Joint Commission standard nor OSHA's bulletin addresses facial recognition. What the Illinois law and the installer's method together set out is the mechanism a hospital builds before the first camera goes live: a notice to staff and visitors, a consent record, a retention schedule, and a privacy sign-off on each camera's placement. JMG's post calls for a documented risk and privacy rationale for every camera, with rules for viewing permissions, retention periods and export controls, and added review in treatment and other privacy-sensitive areas.
Sensors answer whether the person in the room should be there
Iraggi's third layer on the episode is sensor technology, named alongside surveillance, for confirming that the people in a space are the ones authorized to be there. Parabit describes on its own site sensors that monitor occupancy, door status and lighting and alert on loitering, door-ajar events and unauthorized activity, plus a human presence detection product for restricted spaces and after-hours areas. The question each sensor answers is the one Iraggi kept returning to.
People that need to be where they are and who are authorized to be where they are. — Robert Iraggi, Parabit Systems
JMG puts after-hours intrusion detection on pharmacies, laboratories, administrative areas and supply rooms, and ties each detector to a response owner so it never sits as an unowned dashboard event. Yaross's audit of who holds access to his four sensitive zones is the manual version of the same control. Iraggi, who said on the episode that surveillance is very important to make sure the doors are locked, pairs the camera with the sensor: the camera shows a face at a door, the sensor shows a body in a room where the access list says there should be none.
Iraggi drew the contrast with other sectors on the episode. At a stadium the venue entrance and box office shape what a visitor gets for their money; on a manufacturing floor the concern is inventory moving across shelves and production lines and whether the person near it is authorized, with sensors and surveillance doing the watching. The hospital is the hard case because the people who must move freely, from clinicians to the friends and family Security Management described arriving in chaotic or intense emotional conditions, are the same population the controls protect, and the building never gives the installer an empty night.
The next milestone is fixed by the standard: EP 17's worksite analysis comes due every year, and the surveyor expects action on last year's findings. JMG's test for a ready design is five clear answers per door; Marcisz's test is whether a tray passer can still reach the unit. A security director who can produce last year's analysis, this year's zone map and a consent record for every facial recognition camera has done what the standard, the Illinois law and Iraggi each ask for.
Sources
- Workplace Violence Prevention Standards (R3 Report, Issue 30) ↗ · The Joint Commission
- Workplace Violence in Healthcare: Understanding the Challenge (OSHA 3826) ↗ · OSHA
- The Burden of Violence to U.S. Hospitals ↗ · American Hospital Association / University of Washington Harborview Injury Prevention and Research Center
- Unravelling the Complexities of Healthcare Access Control ↗ · ASIS International, Security Management magazine
- 2025 Year-In-Review: Biometric Privacy Litigation ↗ · Privacy World (Squire Patton Boggs)
Featured companies
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Healthcare starts with a company putting its clinicians, service-line leaders, and field engineers on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Service-line buyers vet vendors quietly, and your clinicians become the proof they find while doing it.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.