Skip to content
‹ Back to IndustriesEducation Technology

AI didn't break integrity, it exposed credentialism

Phil Hill argues AI is exposing a preexisting higher-ed flaw: institutions built around credentials rather than demonstrated learning. In his view, better cheating detection won’t solve it; schools need clearer assessment of what students can actually do, drawing on competency-based education, authentic assessment, and frameworks like the University of Sydney’s two-stream model for AI-allowed and AI-excluded work.

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Education Technology teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.

Promoted content from signals in higher ed on MarketScale.

By Felicja Syska · · CredentialismHigher EducationAssessmentCompetency-based Learning
Share

Key takeaways

01

Credentialism—treating the credential as the goal rather than evidence of learning—creates incentives for shortcuts that existed before AI; students pursue credentials as boxes to check rather than milestones in learning.

02

States like Michigan and Texas are redefining postsecondary credentials to include skill certificates alongside degrees, but broader definitions only matter if assessment measures actual learning, not just completion.

03

Hill’s three learning-centered models include competency-based education, authentic assessment, and the University of Sydney’s two-stream assessment framework.

Free workspace

Turn your Education Technology expertise into content.

Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.

Try it Free

Last year a browser extension made college students a simple promise: it would read the quiz in front of them in their course and answer it with one click. It arrived in the middle of the alarm over chatbots. Commentators declared the essay dead, faculty wondered whether any unsupervised assessment could still be trusted, and academic integrity became the main way higher education talked about AI.

Phil Hill, founder of Phil Hill and Associates and publisher of the On EdTech newsletter, thinks that lens points at the wrong problem. He agrees some of the cheating is real, and he also sees a moral panic. In his reading, AI has not created a crisis of integrity. It has exposed a system that built everything around earning the credential and left learning optional. If he is right, better detection will not fix it. Institutions will have to decide what they are actually assessing.

Why shortcuts were always the rational move

Hill's argument starts with incentives. If the credential is the goal, and success means moving students toward it, then any shortcut to the credential looks attractive. "We shouldn't be surprised that that's happening," he said. Cheating is the most visible shortcut. The deeper issue is that many courses were never built to show whether a student had learned anything, only whether they had finished.

AI's role is just exposing it and making it almost impossible to deny the myth that we've been living through for years. — Phil Hill, founder, Phil Hill and Associates

He does not treat credentialism as new, or as a problem that belongs only to higher education. At the Blackboard users conference in July, Stanford's David Labaree spoke about where credentialism came from and why it is a core problem. Labaree did not connect it to AI, but Hill said hearing him sharpened his own thinking. Hill traces the pattern to an American habit: name one ideal path, then treat everything else as the alternative.

His example comes from his years as an Air Force electrical engineer at the end of the Cold War. He wanted to keep doing hands-on engineering and research. The career structure pushed officers toward acquisition, which meant managing large contractors and moving through a fixed sequence: Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, then Washington. By his account, the Soviet military had career tracks for people who wanted to stay operational.

He sees the same binary in American education. It runs from Bill Bennett's early-1980s work defining an ideal K-12 path into college, through what Hill describes as the Obama administration's push for a college degree for all. Even then, he noted, some people were asking how to support everyone headed straight into the workforce.

States are already redefining what counts

Darren, host of the Hard Truths in Higher Ed series on Signals in Higher Ed, pointed to a correction that has drawn little attention. Almost every state has set a goal for the share of adults holding a postsecondary credential, and many of those goals now count far more than degrees. In his home state of Michigan, the 60 by 30 goal counts a skill certificate the same as a college degree.

How state attainment goals define a credential

42
States with adult postsecondary attainment goals
6
Of those states that count degrees alone
20
Count any credential, including certificates, licenses and apprenticeships
55% or 65%
Most common targets for the share of adults with credentials, around 2030

Figures cited by host Darren, Hard Truths in Higher Ed series, Signals in Higher Ed

Hill sees this as one of the system's real strengths. States act as laboratories, and he pointed to the Texas coordinating board's work on alternative credentials, pathways and ways to measure and support them. The weak spot is what happens next. Good ideas tend to stay inside the state that produced them, and Hill does not see comparable effort at the federal level or in work that brings states together.

That matters for the AI debate. A broader definition of credentials does not, on its own, cure credentialism. A certificate can be chased as a box to check just as easily as a degree. Wider recognition only helps if what gets recognized reflects demonstrated learning, and that puts the question right back on assessment.

Removing the measure is not the same as fixing it

The University of Michigan offered a test case. Darren discussed a proposed first-semester grade-covering pilot for first-year students in the College of Literature, Science, and the Arts (LSA), framed around student well-being. The proposal concerned external transcripts: students would still receive course grades and feedback, and the university would retain grades internally. It did not apply to all incoming U-M students. The Faculty Senate's September 30 newsletter reports that President Domenico Grasso requested a pause on September 28, before the planned 2027-28 pilot. The discussion below describes the speakers' views of the proposal, not an implemented university-wide grading policy.

Hill was more skeptical. "I think they're trying to do a shortcut to deal with something as opposed to a deep rethinking," he said, while adding that he truly hopes he is wrong. His concern is a familiar pattern: a measure with well-known flaws gets removed instead of improved, and the gap creates bigger problems.

He pointed to the move away from standardized testing across much of higher education over the past four or five years. In California, he said, faculty are overwhelmed and say they are being asked to teach middle school to incoming students. For Michigan's change to be useful, in his view, it has to be replaced with something that actually encourages learning.

When weighing a grading or testing reform, use Hill's test: what replaces the measure being removed? If nothing new shows what students can do, the reform may only hide the credential problem.

This is where Hill parts ways with a simple anti-grading stance. He is not defending grades as the thing that counts. He is saying institutions have leaned on weak signals of learning, and pulling the signal without building a better one does not bring learning back into focus.

Three models that put learning back at the center

Asked what shows promise, Hill named three approaches. None is new, and he called none of them a panacea. Together they shift the emphasis from completion to demonstration.

  1. Skills and competency-based education. Hill said it has not reshaped higher education as much as he had hoped, but where it exists, at Western Governors University and elsewhere, it has shown real benefits. The key, he said, is finding a way to show that a student has the skill "we think you have." The open problem is embedding it in mainstream education.
  2. Authentic assessment. Even in courses organized the traditional way, faculty can evaluate what students know with better methods than heavy reliance on multiple choice and other easy, flawed formats. Hill was clear that multiple choice still has a place.
  3. Institution-wide AI frameworks, with the University of Sydney as his lead example. Its white paper sets out principles for transforming education in the age of AI that, in his words, go "well beyond the trivial human in the loop type of what I think are banalities."

Hill said he cannot yet point to results from Sydney, but he called its framework one of the best he has seen. It accepts that students need preparation for a world full of AI, and it deals head-on with the downsides instead of treating AI as purely good or purely a threat.

As Hill describes it, Sydney's assessment framework runs two streams. Open assessments assume students can or will use AI, and are designed so the work still produces learning. A separate stream excludes AI, which in practice means proctored, in-person testing and similar formats.

The two-stream design is the most practical answer to the problem Hill laid out at the start. It does not try to keep AI out of every assessment, which the quiz-answering extension suggests is a losing fight. It also does not give up on verifying what a student can do alone. Each assessment has to say up front which kind it is and what it is meant to show.

The risk of swapping one narrow metric for another

Darren raised a trend he sees at many institutions: more work-based learning, closer employer partnerships, and stronger pressure to show that a degree leads to a job. Hill welcomed parts of it. Paying attention to what graduates do after college is good, and employer input reinforces the move toward skills and competencies over the letter A or B on a transcript.

He added two caveats. First, the field should not swing from treating everything as a traditional credential to treating everything as work-based learning. Not every program should be judged by the job a student lands right after finishing. Second, learning has value of its own: learning with others, forming a worldview, becoming an educated citizen.

Darren agreed, calling for a recommitment to the liberal arts. The link back to AI is direct. Trading grade-chasing for placement-chasing would keep the credential problem alive in a different outfit.

The bottleneck is scale, not ideas

Hill returned to Texas as the closest thing to a statewide reckoning. He said it treats the problem as multidimensional and uses multiple metrics, recognizing that some students need immediate jobs and others go on to graduate school, with particular focus on community colleges and regional universities. He sees plenty of good work elsewhere too, but says it sits too often at the margins.

His diagnosis: higher education is not short of ideas. Competency-based programs, authentic assessment and frameworks like Sydney's already exist. What is missing, he said, is the willingness to apply lessons already learned to the mainstream fast enough to meet what he called an existential challenge.

Darren pushed further. He tells both academics and edtech companies that pilots are "the death of your business." Half measures signal that the change does not really matter, and they rarely get enough resources to produce results. In a risk-averse culture, he said, leaders sometimes have to take big swings and even put their position at risk.

For provosts, assessment leads and faculty developers, the takeaway from Hill's argument is not about catching AI misuse. It is about going back to ground zero: what each course is trying to evaluate, and whether its assessments actually show it. Hill admits higher education is good at fooling itself and may find ways to keep doing so. For now, he credits AI with forcing a conversation he says "we should have been having ten years ago."

signals in higher ed

Part of this channel

signals in higher ed

Proven outcomes in higher education, from the people who achieved them.

Visit the channel

Your experts belong here

Every story in MarketScale Education Technology starts with a company putting its implementation leads, instructional designers, and district partners on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.

Procurement teams read long before they ever call, and your implementers get to answer their questions first.

Book DemoSee how it works15 minutes, straight to a calendar.

About the author

FS
Felicja Syska
B2B Weekly

The week in Education Technology, and sixteen other industries, every Monday.

Ten stories, one-line takes, five minutes. Free.

Education Technology: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Education Technology buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. Explore how your experts, customers, and partners can become useful content for buyers and AI search.

Free Trial

You just read one Education Technology expert. Your company is full of them.

This article was produced through MarketScale. The same platform turns your implementation leads, instructional designers, and district partners into the articles, video, and social content Education Technology buyers are searching for. Start a free trial and see it with your own people. For qualifying companies, no credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What your free trial includes

Hands-on access to the MarketScale platform
Media requests to your crowd, remote recording, AI writing tools
No demo required. No credit card.
For qualifying companies. Company confirmation required.

More Education Technology Insights

In 21 of 119 Penn State AI tutor chats, reasoning never reached the homework

Penn State's Suman Saha won a two-year, $199,009 NSF grant to test ALAASKA, an AI tutor that gives hints instead of answers. In its first classroom pilot, 21 of 119 chats showed reasoning missing from submitted work. Grading only final answers may miss real thinking.

  • 01In about one of every six tutoring chats, reasoning appeared in the conversation but not in the student’s submitted answer, suggesting final products alone may miss parts of the problem-solving process.
  • 02Penn State's study compares an AI tutor against equivalent coursework, which isolates the tutor's conversational support from AI use in general.

Nov 21, 2026

Iowa State's $6 million USDA grant covers half of a farm tech training expansion

Iowa State's $6 million USDA grant covers half of a farm tech training expansion

Iowa State University won a $6 million USDA grant toward FIELD Commons, a $12 million, 42,000-square-foot farm tech training addition in Ames. The other $6 million must come as non-federal cash. The plan targets more than 1,000 micro-credentials and 100 employer-connected learning experiences over five years, with hands-on training space as the thing being bought.

  • 01Classroom space is the constraint FIELD Commons is built to remove: Iowa State's farm tech courses, including AI in agriculture, already draw more demand than the lab can hold.
  • 02Only 100 employer-connected learning experiences are planned over five years, about 20 a year if spread evenly, against more than 1,000 micro-credentials, which makes the employer slots the limited resource for ag businesses seeking a technician pipeline.
  • 03Student and educator targets count engagements rather than individual people, so the sharper question for partners is how many credentials get completed and how many lead to jobs.

Nov 20, 2026

Values belong in the core curriculum, says the student leader who resisted Idi Amin

Values belong in the core curriculum, says the student leader who resisted Idi Amin

Olara Otunnu, a former UN ambassador, argues that university education must combine academic rigor with values-based character development and international exposure to produce leaders equipped for uncertain times. His argument draws on his experience leading student resistance to Uganda's Amin regime and his conviction that schools, not just families, bear responsibility for instilling ethics and solidarity.

  • 01International student enrollment creates mutual benefit: foreign students learn democratic values and opportunity in the US, while American students learn from peers across Africa, Europe and Asia, building practical solidarity through direct exchange.
  • 02Top-tier education requires deliberate institutional organizing around two things: students who encounter the world beyond their hometown and teachers who persistently ask ethical questions about right and wrong.

Nov 19, 2026

Explore More Education Technology Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Education Technology.

Browse Education Technology Hub

About the Expert

FS
Felicja Syska

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Education Technology and beyond.

Book a Demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512