Only 25% of shippers in Transporeon's survey use set rules to sort freight lanes
A Transporeon and Adelante SCM survey of 53 shippers found only 25% use defined criteria to choose how each freight lane is sourced. That gap matters. Thin lanes pushed into annual tenders tend to draw defensive pricing, and service-focused scorecards can miss whether awarded carriers actually accept the loads.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Transportation teams put it to work with Partner & Channel Enablement.
Key takeaways
A quarter of shippers decide each lane's sourcing method by written rule; the rest rely on judgment or put nearly every lane through the same process.
Lanes with fewer than a dozen loads a year can draw defensive carrier pricing, and those padded rates can skew the entire award.
Post-award, lane-level tender acceptance can reveal whether the award is holding and whether projected savings will become real.
Free workspace
Turn your Transportation expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
One in four. That is the share of shippers in a new Transporeon and Adelante SCM survey that use defined criteria to decide how each freight lane gets sourced: by annual contract, shorter-term agreement, mini-tender, indexed pricing or planned use of the spot market.
Adrian Gonzalez of Talking Logistics, who made a companion video with Transporeon, picked that number out as the one that stood out to him from the report. Another 45% of respondents vary their approach by lane but mainly on experience and judgment. A further 26% run most or all lanes through the same process. A quarter of shippers decide each lane's sourcing method by written rule; the rest rely on judgment or put nearly every lane through the same process.
For the transportation director now assembling lane lists for 2027, the finding points to a decision that usually gets skipped. Before anyone asks carriers for rates, someone has to decide which lanes belong in the tender at all.
Matching each lane to a buying method
Gonzalez sets out a simple map. A stable, high-volume lane with several qualified carriers is a natural fit for a longer-term deal with a core carrier. A seasonal or volatile lane may do better with a shorter agreement or a mini-tender. And for freight nobody can predict, planned spot buying can beat forcing it into an annual contract it will never honor. The inputs behind that sorting are the ones he says shippers should test first: how predictable volumes are, how accurate the forecasts are, what service and equipment the freight needs, and how attractive the lanes look to carriers.
Thin lanes are where judgment-based sorting gets expensive. ProcureKey, a sourcing software vendor, wrote in a November 19 guide that lanes moving fewer than a dozen loads a year need a decision before the bid package is drafted, because carriers price them defensively and those padded rates can skew the entire award. One badly placed lane can affect the whole bid.
Those messy lanes are also where analytics has had the least to offer so far. In Logistics Management, Bridget McCrea reported that Angi Acocella, a research scientist at the MIT Center for Transportation & Logistics, sees predictive tools working well on high-volume, consistent lanes, while lower-volume, irregular lanes generate more exceptions, swing more week to week and demand more one-off pricing and capacity calls. Acocella sees those lanes as the next opportunity for automation. Until that arrives, a written segmentation rule is the manual version of the same sorting.
Writing the rule down before bids arrive has a precedent outside freight. A 2023 open-access chapter on tendering in Springer's Public Procurement volume argues that buyers should explore and consult the market before a tender opens, because in public tenders the selection model is fixed before bids arrive and what buyers learn from reading them cannot change it. Private shippers have more freedom than public buyers. The point still holds: criteria set after the bids come in tend to follow whichever bid came in lowest.
When the contract premium shrinks
A lane's place in the sourcing mix is not permanent, and the gap between contract and spot rates is one of the clearest signals that it should move. ProcureKey cites the U.S. Bank Freight Payment Index for the comparison below.
Contract versus spot, U.S. truckload
U.S. Bank Freight Payment Index, as cited by ProcureKey
When that premium narrows, rates signed in a looser market start to look expensive, in ProcureKey's words. The guide names two other triggers for pulling a bid forward regardless of the calendar: tender rejections climbing on lanes that used to hold, and a network change such as a plant opening or a customer moving volume. It also notes that bidding once a year, timed so new rates land just before peak season, is mostly an administrative convenience. More teams now add a smaller mid-year event.
ProcureKey offers no break-even figure for when a narrowing spread justifies a rebid, so that threshold is the shipper's to set. A mini-bid, which the guide describes as a four- to 12-week event covering a handful of lanes, is the practical tool for acting on it without reopening the whole network. A shipper with defined segmentation criteria already knows which lanes are candidates. A shipper running every lane through one annual process would have to sort them under time pressure.
Measuring what happens after the award
The survey found service performance is the leading measure of tender success, while execution against plan and spot-market usage rank much lower. That ranking matters, because Gonzalez argues projected savings only become real if the award is carried out. His checklist is concrete. Are loads going to the carriers that won them? Are those carriers accepting? Are planned allocations holding? Do invoices match agreed rates? Are service levels where they should be?
ProcureKey puts a number on why acceptance belongs on that list: a carrier that bids lowest but turns down a third of its tenders ends up costing more than one priced four percent higher. Rejected loads drift to backups or the spot market, so a scorecard built mainly on service can look healthy while the award quietly leaks.
For the first month after award, pull tender acceptance by lane and carrier rather than the savings summary. ProcureKey's guide says that is where the gap between spreadsheet rates and real performance shows up first.
Watching every lane by hand is not realistic for a team running thousands of loads. Brandon Hamilton, systems project manager at St. Onge Co., told Logistics Management that usually only 5% to 10% of shipments need attention, and that AI is getting better at finding them. The same logic applies to post-award monitoring: flag the lanes where acceptance or invoiced cost drifts from plan, and leave the rest alone.
Clean lane data comes before AI
Respondents' technology priorities are practical. According to the report, 54% see the biggest potential impact in comparing bids and modeling award scenarios, and poor or inconsistent data quality is the leading barrier to AI adoption. Those two findings depend on the same thing. Award modeling is only as good as the lane volumes, equipment and service requirements fed into it, which are the same inputs a segmentation rule needs. A shipper that cleans its lane data to sort lanes is also preparing the ground for the tools it says it wants.
There is a fair objection. Fifty-three responses is a small sample, and the authors themselves call the results directional rather than representative. A team relying on experience may also make good lane calls; deep knowledge of a network is a form of criteria. The weakness is repeatability. Judgment that lives in one planner's head cannot be audited, handed to a new hire, or rerun quickly when the spread moves in February.
The shippers who should act first are the ones with many low-volume, irregular lanes, where defensive pricing and unpredictable volume add up fastest. For them, the useful test arrives a few weeks into the 2027 contract year: if acceptance rates on thin lanes sag while the core lanes hold, the sorting rule belonged in the tender all along.
Sources
- Transportation Procurement: Three Questions to Ask Before Your Next Tender ↗
- Introduction - Market Insights Tender Season 2026 EN ↗
- Future of Motor Freight: 6 trends reshaping ... ↗ · Logistics Management
- Freight RFP Process: A Step-by-Step Guide for Shippers ↗
- Tendering and Supplier Selection | Springer Nature Link ↗ · Springer
Featured companies
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Transportation starts with a company putting its fleet managers, logistics engineers, and safety leads on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Fleet and logistics buyers compare quietly, and your operators become the evidence that settles it.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.