Skip to content
‹ Back to IndustriesHealthcare

Answering a licensing board complaint without a lawyer can make it worse

Healthcare attorney Kenda Dalrymple recommends not panicking, promptly notifying your professional liability insurer, and getting experienced legal guidance when a licensing complaint arrives; she warns against responding on your own or in haste.

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Healthcare teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.

Promoted content from I Don't Care on MarketScale.

By Kevin Stevenson · · Licensing BoardsHealthcare ComplianceProfessional License DefenseAttorney Guidance
Share

Key takeaways

01

Dalrymple recommends promptly contacting your professional liability insurer and then an experienced licensing attorney, and avoiding the impulse to answer the complaint yourself.

02

BHEC comprises Texas boards for psychologists, professional counselors, marriage and family therapists, and social workers. Other professions have separate regulators.

03

Interview anecdotes and opinions do not establish universal rules or outcomes. Review generated clinical notes before relying on them.

Free workspace

Turn your Healthcare expertise into content.

Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.

Try it Free

A clinician gets a letter from a licensing board. Before an attorney ever sees it, the clinician may already be drafting a response.

The complaint is unfair. The patient misunderstood. The record will explain everything.

That impulse is understandable. It can also make a hard situation worse.

Healthcare attorney Kenda Dalrymple argues that defending a professional license takes more than confidence in the care you provided. You have to know the process, write a careful response and get experienced guidance before frustration takes over. When a livelihood, a reputation and a professional identity are on the line, she says, the first moves count most.

Dalrymple is managing partner of Dalrymple, Shellhorse & Diamond, LLP in Austin. After roughly a decade in medical malpractice defense, she built a practice representing physicians, nurses, pharmacists and mental health professionals before their licensing boards. She made her case on I Don't Care with Dr. Kevin Stevenson, a former hospital CEO and COO. The two have been friends for more than four decades, going back to their college days at Baylor, so the talk about pressure, mistakes and responsibility was unusually blunt.

The first calls go to the insurer and the lawyer

Stevenson asked the question every licensed professional dreads: what should you do first, and what's the biggest mistake people make in the first 24 hours? Dalrymple's answer starts with something easy to say and hard to do. Don't panic.

Dalrymple’s next recommendation is to contact the professional liability insurer promptly. She warns that delayed reporting can put coverage at risk; this article has not verified the terms of an individual policy.

Dalrymple recommends promptly contacting the insurer and reviewing the applicable policy. This interview does not establish a universal reporting deadline, cancellation rule or entitlement to board-defense coverage. Those details need to be checked against the clinician’s own policy and the board’s notice.

After the insurer, call a lawyer. If you already work with one, start there. If you don't, Dalrymple said the insurance company will connect you with someone who handles licensing matters, and that person can explain how the process works. What she warned against most firmly was feeling pressure to answer the complaint right away, or answering it yourself.

"Back in the old days when things were different and the world was young, you could get a complaint you knew was completely bogus, and you could answer it yourself," she said. "Those days are gone. There is a right way and a wrong way to put together a complaint response to any licensing board, and you need somebody with the expertise to walk you through that."

A complaint does not have to seem credible to require a serious response

Dalrymple described complaints that cover almost anything. A surgeon may face one after a disappointing result. She mentioned a friend on her fourth knee replacement revision, not because anyone did anything wrong, but because her anatomy and the implant parts just don't work well together. A nurse may be accused of doing, or failing to do, something while caring for a patient. A mental health professional may hear that a client didn't like what was said, or felt they weren't believed.

Some complaints barely match anything the clinician remembers. One of Dalrymple's current clients is answering an allegation that bears no resemblance to the single session she recalls having with the complainant three years ago. She suspects the complainant may have her mistaken for someone else. That still doesn't get her off the hook. "You can't file a response with your licensing board that just says, Uh-uh. Didn't happen," Dalrymple said. "It doesn't work that way."

The reason comes down to what a board can actually weigh. Dalrymple pointed to therapists who treat children of divorcing parents. Dalrymple describes cases in which a parent who did not choose the therapist files a complaint. Her account should not be read as a universal rule that any complaint automatically requires termination of treatment or referral. The applicable professional rules and the circumstances of the case matter. In her view, many complaints against mental health professionals are rubbish, and complainants face no downside for lying.

She said a member of the executive staff at the Texas Behavioral Health Executive Council (BHEC), the agency comprising the state boards for psychologists, professional counselors, marriage and family therapists, and social workers, has acknowledged publicly that many complainants are not credible. So the board counts on the licensee to show what really happened, with the records to back it up.

That's why an emotionally satisfying rebuttal is risky. A clinician may believe a complaint is completely unfounded, but the board still needs a response it can evaluate. Telling your side of the story can leave key questions unanswered or create problems you didn't see coming.

Good clinicians, thin records and bad luck

Asked whether most complaints involve bad clinicians, Dalrymple said the pattern depends on the profession. Sometimes good professionals make poor decisions. Often, she said, they're good professionals doing what they should, but their documentation is terrible.

Pharmacy is its own case. Dalrymple called it the single most regulated profession in Texas and described the modern community pharmacy as "literally the sweatshop of the twenty-first century." Pharmacists work twelve-hour shifts, and the smallest lapse can trigger a board inspection. Failing to offer counseling on a new medication used to be a big one. She said that has faded because electronic record systems now won't let pharmacists log out until they click that counseling was offered.

She also said plain bad luck plays a bigger role than people expect. She has seen clients practice for thirty years without incident, then get several complaints in quick succession, the way people say celebrities die in threes. Stevenson added a friend in Waco, a physician he described as meticulous, who has been fighting one case for five years because someone had a bone to pick, kept at it and got traction.

Stevenson also knows how fast an unexpected outcome turns into conflict. Grief, he said, triggers a lot of these complaints, and some people are looking for a payday. Patients and families may be frightened, grieving or searching for an explanation.

He told one on himself. After an emergency laparoscopic appendectomy, still on pain medication, he saw the incisions on his left side, decided the surgeon had operated on the wrong side, and told his wife they were about to be rich. She called him an idiot. The next morning he remembered that the procedure goes in from the other side. Patients who start spinning like that, he noted, are what hospitals and Dalrymple's clients deal with all the time.

For healthcare executives: when one of your clinicians gets a board complaint, is there a clear process for helping them respond, including reporting to the carrier and getting experienced counsel? Or are they left to handle the fear, the deadlines and the uncertainty alone?

A regulatory climate she says breeds fear, not safety

Stevenson asked the bigger question behind all this: as healthcare gets more litigious and more regulated, are we creating safer care or clinicians who are afraid to practice? "I think it is much more of the latter," Dalrymple said.

She said she couldn't think of a single administrative regulation from the medical board, the nursing board, BHEC or the pharmacy board that could be credited with saving a particular person's life. She allowed that, taken together, some rules might make something like a drug interaction less likely. Her larger complaint is philosophical. She sees medicine and advanced practice nursing as "one of the last vestiges of art, education, training, and science," and argues that regulators want medicine to be a recipe the clinician follows. That distrust of judgment and intuition, in her view, shapes how heavy an agency's rules become.

She has felt it personally. About seven or eight years ago, after a twelve-hour day at the nursing board that ended with her client's case dismissed, she drove back to the office and told her law partners the nursing cases were theirs from now on. It wasn't the nurses or the clients, she said. It was the regulatory environment. "To say it's unfriendly is an insult to unfriendly people."

Stevenson, who left the C-suite almost a year ago, said the disillusionment he hears from physicians is astounding. They aren't tired of patient care, he said, but of the administrative weight around it, and many are stepping away or going entrepreneurial to get more control over their lives. He put the share of physicians now employed by a health system, insurer or similar organization at 80% and said nurses have been leaving the profession since right before COVID over documentation and litigation.

Dalrymple has lost track of the clients who told her they wouldn't pay a dollar toward their kids' education if they chose medical school. That stings, she said, because some professions run in families. Pharmacists do. Paramedics do. Doctors used to.

Her case for why that matters is a client who bought a medical practice without doing his due diligence ("Boys and girls, you gotta do your due diligence. Gotta call your lawyer") and endured a multiyear medical board case. Afterward he took a job just to decompress. Riding an elevator, he noticed an executive who didn't look well and asked a few questions. He couldn't shake it, researched it that night and the next morning told the man to get blood work. It was a rare leukemia, caught very early. "A really wonderful doctor is still nothing short of a miracle," Dalrymple said.

AI can help write the note. The clinician still owns it.

If the record is what a board weighs, how the record gets written matters. Technology can cut the administrative work, but it also makes complacency easier. Dalrymple said she hasn't seen a doctor in three or four years who didn't use some kind of scribe. She gets why. A physician can't examine a patient and type notes at the same time, and she said the medical board's rules on what counts as an adequate record are "ridiculously complicated." In her words, the board wants "the great American novel in every client note."

She sees real value in tools that help with transcription and documentation. She described AI built into some therapists' electronic health record systems that records the session and produces a transcript. Once the therapist opens it, the recording is gone and can't be recovered, so the note has to be finished then and there. The therapist can edit the transcript down, and it helps with what she called "white screen syndrome."

She urged anyone using these tools to ask two questions. First, is the vendor collecting, keeping or reselling data from how you and your patients use the platform? Are you, as she put it, making the AI company rich by feeding it a never-ending stream of free data? Second, will you use the tool wisely, or get complacent and let it stand in for your education, training and experience?

The second question is where she sees the biggest problem. Dalrymple recalled an unnamed California lawyer losing his license over unchecked AI-generated citations and an unnamed judge facing sanctions. MarketScale has not independently verified the identities, disciplinary records or outcomes of those cases. These are interview anecdotes, not verified case reports. She has no objection to lawyers using AI for discovery requests or deposition summaries, which she called boring law clerk work.

But the professional is still the captain of the ship, and you don't set it on autopilot and never check on it. She recalled a line from her practice court professor at Baylor, Louis Muldrow.

Your clients aren't paying you to trust your secretary. — Louis Muldrow, as recalled by Kenda Dalrymple

In a clinical setting, that means a generated note still needs review. A polished summary can contain an error, and a tool's ability to produce convincing language says little about whether that language matches what happened in the room.

For organizations adopting AI, the work continues after go-live. Clinicians need to understand their tools, check the output and stay accountable for the final record. Leadership needs to make those expectations clear. The time saved is valuable. So is the attention it takes to catch something wrong.

The response to a mistake can change everything

One of Dalrymple's most telling stories involved a spine surgeon who discovered that a screw had been missed during a lengthy procedure. She said the surgeon told the patient's husband what had happened, took responsibility and explained the plan to fix it. He later spoke with the patient directly, apologized and documented the circumstances.

He could have blamed someone else involved in the procedure. He chose to own the error. Dalrymple said the licensing board dismissed the case after reviewing his care and his response. Later, a physician who had questioned him during the board proceeding brought his own daughter to the surgeon for a consultation. Owning the mistake had earned that physician's trust.

The story makes a point that runs through the whole conversation. An adverse event deserves careful examination, and how the clinician responds matters. Candor, corrective action and documentation give patients, families and reviewers something concrete to assess. It's the opposite of the reflexive rebuttal Dalrymple warns against when a complaint first lands.

Accountability has to survive the uncomfortable conversation

Stevenson tied the spine surgeon's story to his own experience talking with patients and families after something went wrong in a hospital. Those conversations are hard. Leaders have to say what is known, explain what happens next and resist hiding behind institutional language. Patients and families want answers and want their concerns acknowledged. When an error has happened, they want to know how it will be addressed.

Dalrymple also talked about what clinicians carry after a serious mistake. She described a pharmacist involved in a fatal medication error who examined what had happened, took part in the board process and eventually went on to medical school and a career treating critically ill children. It's a painful story about consequences and resilience. It also asks leaders how they support professionals through an event that may change the course of their lives.

An organization's commitment to accountability shows up in these moments: how thoroughly it investigates, how honestly it communicates, what it changes and how it treats the people involved. Dalrymple kept coming back to the everyday habits that sustain a practice: vigilance, continued learning, professionalism and reliable support. They sound ordinary until the board letter arrives. Then they decide whether the response helps or hurts.

That leaves clinicians and executives with a hard question. When something goes wrong, are they ready to take responsibility and do the work that follows, starting with the call to the insurer and the lawyer instead of the draft written in frustration?

I Don't Care

Part of this channel

I Don't Care

Candid healthcare leadership conversations with Kevin Stevenson

Visit the channel

Your experts belong here

Every story in MarketScale Healthcare starts with a company putting its clinicians, service-line leaders, and field engineers on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.

Service-line buyers vet vendors quietly, and your clinicians become the proof they find while doing it.

Book DemoSee how it works15 minutes, straight to a calendar.

About the author

Kevin Stevenson
Kevin StevensonTop Hospital Administrator & Healthcare COO, I Don't Care
B2B Weekly

The week in Healthcare, and sixteen other industries, every Monday.

Ten stories, one-line takes, five minutes. Free.

Healthcare: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Healthcare buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. Explore how your experts, customers, and partners can become useful content for buyers and AI search.

Free Trial

You just read one Healthcare expert. Your company is full of them.

This article was produced through MarketScale. The same platform turns your clinicians, service-line leaders, and field engineers into the articles, video, and social content Healthcare buyers are searching for. Start a free trial and see it with your own people. For qualifying companies, no credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What your free trial includes

Hands-on access to the MarketScale platform
Media requests to your crowd, remote recording, AI writing tools
No demo required. No credit card.
For qualifying companies. Company confirmation required.

More Healthcare Insights

Frequent use of clinical AI tools rose to 34% in Elsevier's 2026 clinician survey

Elsevier's Clinician of the Future 2026 survey found 49% of clinicians use AI at work. Purpose-built clinical AI is gaining fast. Its frequent use rose from 22% in 2025 to 34% this year, yet 41% of nurses say their views are rarely or never sufficiently considered in important organizational decisions.

  • 01A sharper vendor question: which evidence base grounds the tool's answers, and can a clinician see that source at the moment of use? Transparency and authoritative data top clinicians' own list of what builds trust.

Nov 22, 2026

Zoom's stake in Medaica aims to bring the physical exam into video visits

Zoom Ventures made an undisclosed strategic investment in Medaica, whose FDA-cleared M1 telehealth stethoscope supports real-time remote heart and lung auscultation. Zoom already integrates with EHRs including Epic, Oracle Cerner Millennium and Athenahealth, but an investment is not an integration and no combined product has been announced. Cardiology follow-ups and care facilities are highlighted as likely early use cases.

  • 01Video gave telehealth the patient's face; an FDA-cleared remote stethoscope adds the heartbeat, and Zoom now has a financial stake in that second layer.
  • 02Today's cleared capability is real-time heart and lung auscultation; the wider mix of third-party devices, AI analysis and decision support is still in development.
  • 03For health systems with elderly or rural cardiology panels, the sharper vendor question is how exam findings reach the EHR record of the visit.

Nov 21, 2026

How Memorial Hermann measured $37,500 in AI scribe value per ER doctor

How Memorial Hermann measured $37,500 in AI scribe value per ER doctor

Memorial Hermann emergency physicians using Ambience Healthcare's AI documentation generated about $37,500 more in yearly productivity value than non-users. That figure is gross and comparative. It comes from billing data annualized over 160 shifts and excludes software costs, so buyers must build the cost side themselves.

  • 01Memorial Hermann's $37,500 per emergency physician is gross: the gap in work RVUs per clinical hour between AI documentation users and non-users, annualized over 160 ten-hour shifts, before any software or implementation cost.
  • 02Divided out, that gain comes to roughly $234 a shift or about $23 per clinical hour, a practical yardstick to hold against any all-in per-physician cost quote.
  • 03When a vendor puts fees at risk against outcomes, the comparison group, billing source and acuity adjustment become contract terms, because they decide what counts as a gain worth paying for.

Nov 21, 2026

Explore More Healthcare Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Healthcare.

Browse Healthcare Hub

About the Expert

Kevin Stevenson
Kevin Stevenson

Top Hospital Administrator & Healthcare COO

I Don't Care

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Healthcare and beyond.

Book a Demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512