FDA's fortification policy leaves the creatine cookie call to brand teams
FDA’s 1980 fortification policy discourages fortifying cookies, cakes and chips and applies only to a fixed list of essential nutrients. Protein falls within its scope, but fiber, creatine and caffeine do not, leaving brand teams to decide where the line is—by audience, brand fit and whether a labeled dose can survive processing.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Food & Beverage teams put it to work with Customer Stories & Case Studies.
Key takeaways
The one federal document that tells brands not to fortify cookies has nothing to say about the creatine in one: FDA's policy covers only essential nutrients such as protein, not bioactives or fiber.
Heat, stability and ingredient interactions can cut a functional dose in half, so whether the format can carry the dose belongs in the go or no-go review before a recipe is locked.
A protein pastry can be a poor fit for a brand built on clinical doses and a sensible entry product for another brand, especially for shoppers such as GLP-1 users who are making partial diet changes.
Free workspace
Turn your Food & Beverage expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
Three grams of creatine, plus caffeine and citicoline, baked into a cookie and sold as a focus aid. That was one of the samples handed out on the SupplySide Global 2026 show floor in Las Vegas. It also sums up how far functional food has come.
Nick Collias, writing November 19 in SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal, said the skeptics were louder at this year's show than at recent ones. Anyone who reads labels for a living can see the obvious questions. Is 3 grams of creatine enough to do anything for cognition? Is the citicoline, the caffeine or the sugar doing the mental work? Why isn't this a powder?
Tim Avila, who founded and runs the consultancy Systems Bioscience, gave the sharpest warning on stage during the "State of the nutrition industry" session. He said shoppers are very close to deciding that fortification has gone too far, and noted that regulators are already discouraging it. "Protein and fiber and Pop-Tarts is a bridge too far," he said. That leaves a practical question for any R&D director or brand manager approving next year's line extensions: who really decides where the line is?
What FDA's 1980 policy actually reaches
The regulatory language Avila pointed to is old. FDA published its fortification policy, "Nutritional Quality of Foods; Addition of Nutrients," in the Federal Register on January 25, 1980, and codified it at 21 CFR 104.20. The agency's guidance says the policy discourages the indiscriminate addition of nutrients. Its concern is that random fortification could leave people with too much or too little of a nutrient, unbalance the food supply and lead to misleading claims.
FDA lists four principles for what it calls rational fortification. The first is correcting a dietary shortfall linked to a recognized public health need, the way folic acid in enriched grains does. The second is restoring nutrients that storage and processing strip out. The third is keeping added vitamins, minerals and protein balanced against how many calories a food provides. The fourth is ensuring that a substitute food, such as an almond spread used in place of almond butter, matches the nutrition of the food it replaces.
The policy names cookies, cakes and chips directly as foods that should not be fortified at all. FDA's concern is that fortified snacks could lead consumers to believe they can swap out naturally nutrient-dense foods and still eat well. The agency says it wrote its question-and-answer guidance because industry, other federal agencies and academia kept asking how to apply these principles, which suggests the line has been hard to read for decades, not just since this year's show.
FDA states that its guidance documents do not establish legally enforceable responsibilities, and that "should" in a guidance means recommended, not required. Per SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal, the fortification policy becomes binding only when a product makes a "more" or "healthy" claim.
The scope is narrower than the philosophy. The policy applies only to a fixed list of essential nutrients. Protein is on that list. Fiber, creatine and caffeine are not. The one federal document that tells brands not to fortify cookies has nothing to say about the creatine in one.
That split matters for the product brief. A protein pastry at least falls within the policy's subject matter, even if the guidance argues against it. A focus cookie built on bioactives sits outside the policy entirely. In both cases FDA has little power to enforce the line, which leaves brands and their customers to draw it, and that's a harder job than following a rule.
The case for the protein pastry
Joshua Schall, a functional nutrition consultant who started out in sports nutrition, told Collias the answer depends on whose name is on the box. A brand built on transparency and clinically dosed products has to ask whether a protein pastry dilutes what it stands for. A different brand could put out a similar product and find it brings a lot of new shoppers to the brand.
His stronger argument concerns the shopper's starting point. Many consumers, including people on GLP-1 medications, aren't trying to overhaul their diets in one move, Schall said. They want to go partway, from A to K rather than A to Z in his phrasing. He acknowledged that a protein pastry can look like slop to industry insiders and said it still serves a real purpose for a sizable group of buyers.
The one federal document that tells brands not to fortify cookies has nothing to say about the creatine in one.
Food researchers have described the same pull for years. A 2013 review in Asian Social Science by researchers at Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman and UCSI University in Malaysia observed that the main selling point of functional foods is letting people eat more healthily without changing their habits, because consumers say they want healthy food yet resist changing what they eat. The review is a literature survey focused on Malaysia, so it describes a long-standing consumer tension rather than measuring 2026 demand. It does suggest that Avila's wall and Schall's A to K describe the same shopper, one who wants the benefit without giving up the pastry.
Avila's warning still holds for some products. For a brand whose customers trust it because of clinical doses, a fortified snack that delivers a token amount works against that trust, and no regulator needs to say so for the damage to happen.
Four gates before a fortified launch
Schall doesn't treat "should this product exist" as one question. He breaks it into four that the science and business sides can work through together, and he sets a blunt standard: if the team can only shrug at any one of them, the product probably shouldn't exist yet.
- Who is it for? Place the consumer on their nutrition path, from first-time functional buyer to clinical-dose regular.
- Does it fit the brand? Ask whether the brand's customers have given it permission to go there.
- Can the format carry the dose? A dose can lose half its strength to heat, stability problems or reactions with other ingredients, and a reformulation costs a lot.
- Are all teams aligned? Schall says breakthroughs happen when the science and business sides make the decision together and keep talking frankly.
The third gate is where ingredient suppliers are competing hardest, judging by this year's Ingredient Idol food and beverage contest at the same show. Scott Miller of SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal reported that the organizers expanded the GLP-1 category to five finalists because there were so many strong entries, with brain health as the other category. Several finalists pitched themselves on surviving the format.
Super Beta Glucan Inc. presented Immulink MBG Lion's Mane as water soluble and heat stable, with beta-glucans concentrated to at least 70% to support an effective dose, according to the company. Saanroo's Trpti uses LipiSperse delivery technology to bring oleoylethanolamide, usually sold in capsules because it is unstable in water, into gummies, beverages and powders. Weishardt International's Naticol Tripeptide relies on a very low molecular weight to address the solubility and absorption problems collagen peptides can have.
Formo Foods made a related pitch for its precision-fermented Enhanced Casein, saying unpublished research shows its higher purity allows higher protein inclusions. That speaks to the same gate from another direction: how much active ingredient a format can physically hold before taste or texture gives out.
These are supplier claims, not results from any particular snack, and the difference matters. For a team planning a baked or high-heat product, the useful question to a supplier is what share of the labeled dose survives its specific process and shelf life, asked before the recipe is set rather than after the first stability pull.
Letting the shelf sort it out
Schall also argued against mocking what's already on shelves. The market doesn't need 50 protein popcorns, he said, any more than it needs 50 conventional ones, and shoppers will drop the weaker entries on their own. His example: the customer who realizes that another fiber soda does no more than a glass of seltzer with a spoonful of fiber supplement stirred in.
That's a buying decision, not a regulation, and it is the test that will matter most for the focus cookie. Schall sees small brands taking big swings as how the category moves forward, even when most of the swings miss. "The best and the brightest products in our space are standing on the graves of the ones that failed before them," he said. For a brand team, the four gates are a way to be sure that a miss is a deliberate risk and not something that could have been caught on the label review before launch.
Sources
- Should your functional food or drink even exist? ↗ · SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal
- Guidance for Industry: Questions and Answers on FDA’s Fortification Policy | FDA ↗
- Probiotics, lion’s mane represented in Ingredient Idol F&B 2026 ↗ · SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal
- Functional Food: A Growing Trend among the Health Conscious ↗
Featured companies
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Food & Beverage starts with a company putting its plant managers, quality leads, and R&D teams on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Processors and grocery buyers vet suppliers hard, and your operations people are the ones who can satisfy them.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.