Price ranks seventh when shoppers pick store-brand bakery goods
Shoppers buying store-brand bakery goods rank price seventh: 44% cite lower price vs. 79% packaging and 74% freshness. Kroger, Aldi, H-E-B and Sam’s Club are responding with meal lines, member testing and reformulation, while Wegmans is tightening ingredient standards—raising the bar for suppliers.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Food & Beverage teams put it to work with Customer Stories & Case Studies.
Key takeaways
When 79% of store-brand bakery buyers point to packaging and 44% point to price, the label on the box is doing more selling than the number on the tag.
National brands still hold the edge on novelty, seasonal items and promotions in deli salads and dips; store brands win on freshness, local sourcing and everyday value, so the two compete for different reasons in the same case.
Free workspace
Turn your Food & Beverage expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
Ask shoppers why they put a store-brand cake or loaf of bread in the cart, and price comes in seventh. In a survey commissioned by Supermarket Perimeter and run by Cypress Research, 79% of store-brand bakery buyers cited appealing packaging and 74% cited freshness, while lower price drew 44%. Food Business News, Supermarket Perimeter's sister publication, laid out the findings on Nov. 9 in a report by Monica Watrous.
The audience is close to universal. Over the past year, 92% of the shoppers surveyed purchased fresh bakery items under a store brand. Store-brand grab-and-go foods reached 85% of them, and store-brand sliced deli meat or cheese reached 82%.
That ranking changes what a fresh store brand has to be good at. A brand that sells on price needs a tight cost sheet. A brand that sells on packaging, freshness and taste needs a product development pipeline, and several of the biggest US grocers spent 2026 building one. For a private brand director, a deli merchandiser or a co-manufacturer bidding on a prepared-meal program, the question is what that pipeline now asks of them.
Packaging beats price in the bakery case
Grab-and-go follows the same pattern. Packaging leads at 77%, followed by taste at 70%, quality at 68%, freshness and nutrition at 64% each, and convenience at 61%. Lower price trails at 49%. More than half of respondents rated store-brand grab-and-go items as better or much better quality than national brands.
When 79% of store-brand bakery buyers point to packaging and 44% point to price, the label on the box is doing more selling than the number on the tag. Packaging tops both lists, which suggests that what a shopper sees in the first glance at a clamshell or bakery box carries more weight than its cost in fresh departments. Darren Jones, director of private brands at Reser's Fine Foods, told Food Business News that price, service and assortment have become baseline expectations for retailers, and that each needs a distinct strength shoppers associate with the store.
The case against reading too much into this sits in the same data. Price still comes up for nearly half of bakery and grab-and-go buyers, so value hasn't left the conversation. In some categories, including potato and pasta salads, protein salads, cream cheese spreads and dips, plenty of shoppers buy both national and store brands. For those products, the research found that national brands keep the edge on premium positioning, taste, unique products, seasonal and limited-time items, promotions and packaging. Store brands come out ahead on freshness, value, lower price, local sourcing and portion variety.
Packaging shows up on both sides of the ledger, which is the useful detail. Store brands win the everyday attributes. National brands still own novelty and the promotional calendar. For operators whose deli store brand offers no seasonal or limited-time items, that suggests they could be ceding part of the list to national brands.
Meal programs carry the fresh growth
The broader store-brand numbers give that shift some scale. Figures from the Private Label Manufacturers Association and market researcher SPINS, both cited in the Food Business News report, show steady share gains, with younger households doing most of the pushing.
Store brands by the numbers
Private Label Manufacturers Association; SPINS
The gap between dollar and unit growth, about 2.7 points by simple subtraction, indicates that most of 2025's gain came from more spending per item rather than many more items. The figures don't separate inflation from shoppers trading up, so that gap is a prompt for category managers to check their own mix, not a verdict.
Kroger expanded its Private Selection line earlier this year in response to consumer demand for convenient meal solutions, adding frozen entrees and refrigerated deli meals, among them a seasoned whole roasted chicken and a ready-to-cook chicken parmesan. On a September earnings call, chief executive Greg Foran said Kroger's brands are gaining share in deli and bakery, and he pointed to rotisserie chickens and sushi as growth drivers. According to Numerator data, Kroger's fresh private label business grew by $420 million over the past year, with the gains spanning produce, meat, deli and prepared foods, seafood and in-store bakery.
Aldi took a narrower route. In early October it introduced seven refrigerated ready-made meals at select stores: five single-serve options priced under $8 and two family-size meals, built around proteins such as chicken breast and smoked beef brisket. Kitchen Food Company, which supplies the line, said it tested hundreds of recipes in development. H-E-B opened the year with Higher Harvest, a premade meal line shaped by its dietitians and wellness teams, with some items topping 50 grams of protein per serving.
Jones ties the momentum to shoppers hunting for dinner shortcuts and deciding at the last minute in the store. He also points to online meal services, which have put more pressure on grocers to make grab-and-go formats competitive on quality, flavor and value.
Member panels, icing formulas and spreadsheets
Sam's Club shows what the development side looks like at full scale. More than 200,000 members help shape the Member's Mark label, weighing in on ingredients, formulations, packaging, materials, flavors and product concepts. Chief merchant Myron Frazier said at the Groceryshop conference in September that thousands of products may be in members' homes for testing at any given time.
The Member's Mark Thanksgiving Feast is his worked example. Members asked for an appetizer, an extra dessert, alternative proteins and more elevated sides, down to green beans with cranberries. Member data also pointed the team toward a smoked turkey instead of a raw one, which removes the prep. This year's meal serves 16 for under $160, which works out to about $10 a person by simple division, and includes boneless ham, hickory smoked turkey, Yukon Gold mashed potatoes, a charcuterie tray and two 12-inch pumpkin pies.
Reformulation is the other heavy lift. In January, Sam's Club rolled out its Made Without commitment, removing dozens of ingredients from its products; reworking the bakery icing to drop certain certified synthetic colors while keeping its consistency and vibrancy took what the retailer called exhaustive development. Wegmans said this year that every item in its in-store bakeries now meets its own ingredient standard, with artificial colors, dyes, flavors and unnecessary preservatives removed and colors drawn from sources such as turmeric, annatto, beets and cabbage. FMI, the Food Industry Association, found retailers citing dye removal and simpler ingredient statements as ways to stay relevant, especially with younger shoppers.
That workload is where Reid Swanson, vice president of grocery retail at Centric Software, sees grocers straining. Speaking at Groceryshop 2026, as recounted in a Centric-sponsored Progressive Grocer piece, he argued that most grocers aren't built to run a private label practice: specification, procurement and compliance systems sit in silos, and spreadsheets and email stop scaling as SKU counts grow and development moves in-house. His pitch, unsurprisingly from a software vendor, is product lifecycle management (PLM) software that puts retailers, suppliers and co-manufacturers on the same product record from brief to shelf. The pressures he lists are concrete, though: fast-moving trends, changing regulations, tariff and weather shifts in raw material sourcing, and state recyclability and extended producer responsibility rules for packaging.
Co-manufacturers quoting a fresh private label program should ask what the product will be tested against before pricing it. A member home-testing panel or a bakery-wide ingredient standard sets the reformulation work, and that work can cost more than the price gap.
Where the store-brand sale happens
The survey also shows where shoppers get nudged. In-store displays ranked as the most effective way to drive fresh private label purchases, named by 77%. Next came weekly printed or digital ads at 54%. Loyalty programs and store websites or apps tied at 44%, followed by shelf signage (42%), recipes (40%) and sampling (31%). Packaging is the top-rated attribute, and displays are the one place where it reaches the shopper directly.
Those decisions happen fast. In a separate Supermarket Perimeter report on the meat case by Keith Loria, ButcherBox chief commercial officer Reba Hatcher estimated that shoppers in a physical meat department decide in about 13 seconds, often picking that night's dinner. That's a different category, but it's the same perimeter, and it explains why a box that reads well from the aisle earns its 79%.
Trust gives retailers a head start national brands can't easily copy. Seventy-seven percent of Supermarket Perimeter respondents agreed that trust in a grocery store carries over to its fresh store-brand foods. FMI found that 56% of shoppers call their primary store's private brand very or extremely important in choosing where to shop. Nearly 85% of private brand assortments are now available online, per FMI, and private brand online sales grew 5.2% last year, so the digital shelf matters too.
The number suppliers should plan around comes from FMI, and Food Business News and Progressive Grocer both cite it: 86% of retailers intend to moderately or significantly increase private brand investment over the next two years, and 95% of retail executives call private brands extremely or very important. For a co-manufacturer with deli or bakery capacity, that points to more briefs arriving, many of them written around packaging, ingredient standards and meal occasions. Price will come up eventually. On this survey's evidence, it won't be the first item on the brief.
Sources
- The power of private label on the perimeter ↗ · Food Business News
- Turn Private Label Into a Competitive Advantage ↗ · Progressive Grocer
- Grass-fed goes mainstream ↗
Featured companies
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Food & Beverage starts with a company putting its plant managers, quality leads, and R&D teams on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Processors and grocery buyers vet suppliers hard, and your operations people are the ones who can satisfy them.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.