Yale study models plant wall cutting lab CO2 to outdoor levels with 363 modules
Tuning matters most. In Yale's living-wall study, adjusting lighting and airflow direction produced a 43-fold improvement in the system's ability to remove CO2, so facilities and HVAC teams should specify living walls the way they specify air-handling equipment.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Building Management teams put it to work with Customer Stories & Case Studies.
Key takeaways
Typical HVAC systems dilute indoor CO2 with outdoor air, so they cannot bring indoor levels below outdoor levels, which typically hover at about 428 ppm in the US, according to NOAA monitoring data. A plant-based system that removes CO2 could get a room below that.
A plant wall's CO2 performance varied 43-fold depending on lighting and airflow direction, so fan orientation and light intensity belong in the spec, along with the plant count.
Before buying a plant wall for air quality, ask for measured CO2 removal per module, the direction air moves through the root zone, and the light level the figures assume.
Free workspace
Turn your Building Management expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
Turn the fans around and the plants do better work. In a sealed test chamber at the Yale Science Building, air pushed through a plant module from the roots up to the leaves removed nearly 39% more carbon dioxide than air sent the other way under comparable light. The result comes from a Yale-led study published in the journal Energy & Buildings and described by Yale News on November 12.
In the team's simulations at peak performance, at least 363 modules were needed to bring indoor CO2 concentrations in line with or below outdoor levels. For operators running air-handling plants in dense cities, that suggests a different tool could become available. Conventional ventilation handles indoor CO2 by mixing in outdoor air. The Yale system, called the Active Modular Phytoremediation System (AMPS), removes CO2 from the air. That means it can in principle do something ventilation can't: bring a room below the CO2 level outside.
The limit built into ventilation
The mechanism is simple. An HVAC system lowers indoor CO2 by drawing in outside air to dilute what occupants exhale. Dilution can get close to the outdoor concentration but can never go below it. Outdoor CO2 in the US typically sits at about 428 parts per million, according to NOAA monitoring data the researchers cite.
Not long ago that limit was a technicality. The Yale team points to earlier research linking long exposure above 700 to 1,000 ppm with effects on health and cognition. Their own analysis of real-world data found that homes and offices in urbanized areas already exceed 700 ppm in the afternoon and at night. The researchers are careful on the health side: current atmospheric levels aren't acutely harmful, and they say more research is needed to fully understand how CO2 affects people over time.
Lead author Phoebe Mankiewicz Ledins, a postdoctoral associate with the Yale Institute for Biospheric Studies and Yale's Center for Ecosystems + Architecture, described the long-range problem plainly: buildings may eventually need air-handling systems that push indoor CO2 below outdoor levels, and most aren't built to do it.
Where indoor CO2 is heading
Yale News, reporting on the Yale-led study in Energy & Buildings
Inside the AMPS test chamber
The hardware is rows of 3D-printed modules. Each module holds three hydroponic plants: golden pothos, wood sorrel and Saint John's wort. Fans push room air through the foliage and through the substrate where the roots grow. Photosynthesis pulls out CO2 and releases oxygen. The team came from Yale's schools of architecture, public health, the environment and engineering, with coauthors from Purdue University, New York University and the engineering consultancy Buro Happold.
In the chamber, the researchers changed airflow direction, light intensity, growing medium and the lighting the plants were raised under. Then they measured CO2 going into and coming out of each module. Airflow direction turned out to be one of the biggest factors. The team thinks the 39% gain from root-to-leaf flow probably comes from the interplay between leaf photosynthesis and microbes living around the roots, though it says the exact mechanism needs more study. In practical terms, the direction a fan blows is now a performance setting someone has to get right at installation.
To scale the result up, the team took data from an occupied 336-cubic-meter laboratory and ran many simulated versions of the system with different module counts, layouts, lighting and airflow. Depending on airflow direction and light, offsetting the room's CO2 emissions took anywhere from 95 to 3,653 modules. With both set optimally, at least 363 modules were needed to bring indoor CO2 to outdoor levels or lower. Several simulation runs produced pockets of air below the outdoor concentration.
The study reports two different targets. Offsetting a room's CO2 emissions means keeping up with what occupants exhale, and that took 95 to 3,653 modules depending on setup. Matching or beating outdoor air is the harder goal, and it took at least 363 modules even with lighting and airflow at their best.
Ledins said tuning lighting and airflow direction produced a 43-fold improvement in the system's ability to remove CO2. She took on the usual complaint about plant-based air cleaning, that it needs too many plants to work. Her answer is that the complaint holds when lighting and airflow are wrong. The team's architectural modeling of the lab found that a 363-module system would fit without limiting how the space is used.
Light, weight and air on the spec sheet
For a facilities director or mechanical engineer, the study suggests a living wall aimed at air quality is equipment with operating settings. Light intensity and airflow direction drove most of the 43-fold spread, so both would need to be specified, controlled and maintained the way fan speeds and setpoints are today. Plant count tells you little on its own.
Weight is the other line item. Commercial plant walls show the scale involved. Sempergreen lists a saturated weight of roughly 40 to 45 kilograms per square meter for its outdoor Flexipanel facade system, and says the full design must also account for the supporting structure, fixings and wind loads. The manufacturer also notes that loading, drainage, waterproofing and access arrangements are considerably easier to coordinate before construction begins. A plant wall that's part of the HVAC strategy would likely face the same structural review.
The Yale researchers also list possible co-benefits: removal of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), a more varied indoor microbiome, and the calming effect of being around living things. This study didn't measure those. The VOC claim arrives just as facility teams are paying closer attention to materials. Facility Executive's Mary Ellen McCandless reported on The Heat Inside, a new report from the International Facility Management Association (IFMA) and UL Research Institutes' Chemical Insights. It found that every ceiling, wall and floor material tested at 73°F and 95°F emitted VOCs. With few exceptions, total VOC and aldehyde levels rose at the higher temperature. Common certifications such as GREENGUARD and Cradle to Cradle Certified usually test at a single temperature and humidity.
For operators in buildings exposed to heat events, that makes indoor air a moving target. Any plant system's VOC claims would deserve the same scrutiny across temperatures that the IFMA report applies to finishes.
The strongest objection to reading too much into this is the evidence base. It's one sealed chamber plus simulations built on one lab, and an occupied building brings changing daylight, uneven maintenance and occupancy that rises and falls through the day. The root-to-leaf effect is also unexplained so far, which makes it harder to predict how other plant mixes or module designs would behave. For now AMPS is a design framework, and it should be judged that way.
When a vendor pitches a plant wall for air quality, ask three things: which direction air moves through the root zone, what light intensity the performance numbers assume, and what CO2 removal per module was measured going in and coming out.
Counting the payoff in the room
A CO2 sink is an awkward fit for an energy-first scorecard. Grow lights and fans add electrical load, and the benefit shows up in the air people breathe rather than on the utility bill. Tyler Haak, Global Digital Energy Solutions Service League Leader at Schneider Electric, made the broader case on a Schneider Electric-sponsored episode of the Buildings Podcast with editor Janelle Penny. Organizations default to energy metrics because they're easy to track, he argued, and buildings account for about 30% of global energy use. He suggested asking instead whether the building helps the organization do its job: better patient experience in healthcare, research continuity on a campus, labs good enough to keep top faculty.
That framing helps sort out who would care first. Labs like the one the Yale team modeled are the obvious candidates, along with urban offices and residences where the study found CO2 already above 700 ppm in the afternoon and at night. Buildings in cleaner suburban or rural air, where outdoor ventilation still has room to work, have less reason to move soon.
The real test is data from an occupied space showing a tuned AMPS installation holding CO2 at or below outdoor levels through a full working day, outside the chamber and the simulations. If that happens, plant count, light level and fan direction will start showing up in mechanical specifications.
Sources
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Building Management starts with a company putting its facilities engineers, energy managers, and service technicians on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Owners and facilities teams pick on trust, and your engineers turn that trust into inbound conversations.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.