Skip to content
MarketScale
‹ Back to IndustriesEducation Technology

How do Americans Define Success?

Michael B. Horn, Diane Tavenner, and Todd Rose discuss how Americans are redefining success beyond traditional markers like college degrees and white-collar jobs. A Populace study shows that people increasingly prioritize community, financial security, and meaningful work over higher education credentials. This shift has significant implications for K-12 education policy and how schools prepare students for the future.

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Education Technology teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.

Promoted content from The Future of Education with Michael Horn on MarketScale.

By Michael B. Horn · Defining Success in AmericaDiane TavennerK-12 EducationMichael B. Horn
Share

Key takeaways

01

A Populace study found Americans are shifting away from viewing a college diploma as a primary marker of success.

02

Community belonging, financial security, and meaningful work are emerging as top components of how Americans define success.

03

The evolving definition of success challenges K-12 and higher education systems to realign their goals with what individuals and society actually value.

Get featured

Want to get featured in MarketScale Education Technology?

Create a free MarketScale workspace and get your company's expertise featured across our Education Technology coverage. No credit card, no demo required.

Request an invite

How do Americans define success? That's a loaded question, and one guaranteed to illicit multiple answers depending on who answers it and under what context.

Recently, the traditional view of success, often interlinked with higher education and subsequent white-collar employment, has been scrutinized. A growing discourse suggests that success might have a more nuanced definition, encompassing more than just academic and financial achievements. This re-evaluation seems to be a timely response to the evolving societal and economic dynamics, where the "college for all" ideology has shown cracks, and alternative pathways to success have emerged. The stakes are high, as this conversation could reshape educational policies, societal norms, and individual aspirations.

Success might have a more nuanced definition, encompassing more than just academic and financial achievements.

So, how do Americans define success today, and how does this definition influence how we approach education? Does the conventional pathway through higher education still hold the same allure, or are Americans leaning towards a broader, more individualized interpretation of success?

The Future of Education: Class Disrupted, hosted by Michael B. Horn and Diane Tavenner, explores these critical questions in a recent episode featuring Todd Rose, Co-Founder & CEO of Populace. The discussion delves into how Americans define success and the implications of these definitions on K-12 education and beyond.

Highlights from Horn, Tavenner, and Rose's conversation include:

  • A new Populace study revealed a shift in the perception of success, moving away from traditional markers like higher education to aspects like community, financial security, and meaningful work.
  • The rank of a college diploma as a marker of success has significantly plummeted, reflecting a changing attitude towards higher education and its correlation with success.
  • The ongoing paradigm shift challenges the existing education system to realign with the evolving definitions of success and the aspirations of the individuals it serves.

Todd Rose, with his extensive background in education and his position as the CEO of Populace, brings a wealth of knowledge to this conversation. He's a best-selling author known for his works like "The End of Average" and "Collective Illusions." His insights challenge the conventional narratives around success, urging a rethink of the existing educational paradigms to serve individuals better and prepare them for a life imbued with personal and communal meaning. This episode pushes the boundaries of the conventional discourse, urging educators, policymakers, and individuals to re-evaluate the entrenched beliefs surrounding success and education.

The Future of Education with Michael Horn

Part of this channel

The Future of Education with Michael Horn

Michael Horn interviews the people redesigning how students learn

Visit the channel

Your experts belong here

Every story in MarketScale Education Technology starts with a company putting its implementation leads, instructional designers, and district partners on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.

Procurement teams read long before they ever call, and your implementers get to answer their questions first.

Get your team featuredSee how it works15 minutes, straight to a calendar.

About the author

Michael B. Horn
Michael B. HornSpeaker, Writer & Advisor on the Future of Education, Clayton Christensen Institute

Michael Horn speaks and writes about the future of education and works with a portfolio of education organizations to improve the life of each and every student. He is the co-founder of and a distinguished fellow at the Clayton Christensen Institute for Disruptive Innovation, and host of the Future of Education podcast on MarketScale.

Follow Education Technology Insights

Get new expert content in your inbox.

Education Technology: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Education Technology buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. See how AI describes your company today, and where competitors show up instead.

Free workspace

You just read one Education Technology expert. Your company is full of them.

This article was produced through MarketScale. The same platform turns your implementation leads, instructional designers, and district partners into the articles, video, and social content Education Technology buyers are searching for. Create a free workspace and see it with your own people. No credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What you get, free

Your own MarketScale Studio workspace
One video edit a month, on us
AI writing, editing, and publishing tools
In-platform coaching to learn the system

More Education Technology Insights

AI detectors are turning into audit tools, not enforcement, in higher ed

AI detectors are turning into audit tools, not enforcement, in higher ed

AI detection tools can be used to review student writing, but their results are not definitive. In 2026, colleges are putting more emphasis on AI literacy, assessment redesign and clear guidance for acceptable AI use than on detection alone.

  • 0186% student AI use (Digital Education Council survey, cited by Community College Daily) makes “ban and catch” workflows expensive at scale. Training, course design, and tool governance become the controllable levers.
  • 02OECD’s 2026 Outlook warns that better-looking work with GenAI can disappear or reverse on exams without it, a signal that assessment design is now a learning-outcomes control, not a pedagogy preference.

Sep 7, 2026

Workforce Pell will cover 8- to 15-week trades programs starting in July 2026

Workforce Pell will cover 8- to 15-week trades programs starting in July 2026

A final U.S. Department of Education rule makes 8- to 15-week training eligible for Pell Grants, effective July 20, 2026. Eligibility is tied to completion, employment, and earnings measures. For contractors and HR leaders, it adds a federal funding option for short-term technician training, if programs meet the rule’s standards.

  • 01The 70% completion and 70% employment thresholds turn Workforce Pell into a performance contract, not a blank-check subsidy, when selecting school partners.
  • 02For employers, written training agreements are now a procurement artifact: institutions can outsource up to 25% of instruction, and Registered Apprenticeship sponsors up to 49%, shaping how companies staff labs, instructors, and OJT.
  • 03State-by-state approval is the choke point. Governors and workforce boards decide which occupations qualify before federal sign-off, so multi-state employers will see uneven program availability.

Sep 5, 2026

Back-to-school IT teams are buying EdTech in a market where half the funding sits with 10 firms

Back-to-school IT teams are buying EdTech in a market where half the funding sits with 10 firms

New Market Pitch’s July 13, 2026 ranking says the top 10 EdTech startups hold about 50.2% of total funding in its filtered ranking; BYJU’S accounts for about 15.1% and is listed at about $6.0B raised. EdTech Digest’s 2011 profile of Wishbone describes an organization that links donors online with at-risk high school students to fund after-school and summer programs.

  • 01Funding tables can hide procurement risk: New Market Pitch lists some entries with “partial” confidence and flags “acquired” statuses without naming acquirers, so buyers should treat capital rankings as a starting point, not due diligence.
  • 02Some education initiatives behave like supply chains, not software: EdTech Digest’s description of Wishbone’s model highlights the operational work in vetting, publishing, funding, and progress updates, workflows that live outside the LMS.

Sep 4, 2026

Explore More Education Technology Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Education Technology.

Browse Education Technology Hub

About the Experts

Michael B. Horn headshot
Michael B. Horn

Co-founder and CEO, Populace; Author and Education Expert

Clayton Christensen Institute

Michael B. Horn is a co-founder of the Clayton Christensen Institute and a leading voice on disruptive innovation in education. He is the author of several books on education reform, including 'Blended' and 'From Reopen to Reinvent.' Horn co-hosts 'The Future of Education: Class Disrupted' podcast, where he explores how learning and schooling are evolving.

DT
Diane Tavenner

Co-host, The Future of Education: Class Disrupted; Founder, Summit Public Schools

Summit Public Schools

Diane Tavenner is the founder and former CEO of Summit Public Schools, a network of charter schools known for personalized learning. She is a co-host of the Class Disrupted podcast and a prominent advocate for reimagining K-12 education.

TR
Todd Rose

Co-Founder & CEO

Populace

Todd Rose is the co-founder and CEO of Populace, a think tank focused on understanding what people truly want for themselves and society. He is a best-selling author known for 'The End of Average' and 'Collective Illusions,' and formerly taught at the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Education Technology and beyond.

Book a 15-minute demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512