Kongusto’s Joel Ciniero on how fixed call center rates can lead to churn
Many clients expect a call center price fixed for 24, 36 or 48 months, and the core of that price is the agent’s salary. Kongusto founder Joel Ciniero says a frozen price can push a call center to churn out its best people to protect margins, a pattern he calls planned churn. He argues that building a raise mechanism into the contract can reduce that pressure—though buyers should validate the trade-offs with their own data.
This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Business Services teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.
Key takeaways
For companies that outsource support, how raises will be handled is worth raising when a contract is first discussed, before year one ends and agents start to expect a raise.
For buyers comparing RFP responses or renewals, whether a quote plans for raises at all could be a useful signal of how a provider will treat its top performers.
Free workspace
Turn your Business Services expertise into content.
Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.
The first year of an outsourced call center contract tends to be the good one. The client has spotted its best agents, a few of them are what Kongusto founder Joel Ciniero calls rock stars, and the client's own customers can tell the difference. Ciniero calls it the honeymoon year.
Then year one ends. In the sixth video of his Dirty Little Call Center Secrets series, which Telecom Reseller published on November 13, Ciniero walks through what often happens next, a pattern he calls planned churn. In his telling, "the game is rigged going into it": many clients expect a price fixed for 24, 36 or 48 months, and pushing a call center to hold that price is the same as telling it to let go of its best people. He says some clients have moved their business to Kongusto, a nearshore outsourcing company, for this reason alone.
For the procurement director or customer care VP signing that contract, the question is practical. What happens to the best agents when the per-agent price can't move?
Inside the all-in agent rate
Call center pricing usually comes as one number per agent. Ciniero describes it as an all-in figure covering the agent's salary, taxes, insurance, health care and vacation, plus the desk, phone, computer, power, coffee, toilet paper and conference room. The largest piece is the salary, set at the market rate for the skills the program needs.
Those lines don't change the same way over time. A desk costs the same in month 30 as it did in month one. An agent who has spent a year learning a client's products and customers is a different matter, at least if the provider wants to keep that agent. A fixed rate holds every line steady, including the one that tenure pushes up.
In Ciniero's description, one all-in price per agent covers salary at the market rate for the role, the employment costs on top of it (taxes, insurance, health care, vacation) and workspace overhead from equipment and power down to supplies. Salary is the core cost, and it is the line that moves when agents earn raises.
How the year-two squeeze works
After twelve months, the agents hired at the start think what any professional would think. They have grown in the job and expect a raise. A well-run provider, Ciniero says, runs performance reviews, proposes an increase to the client and passes the raises through, on the reasoning that someone with a year on the account is worth more than someone who started yesterday.
Many clients, though, treat the service like an equipment lease. "That's not real," Ciniero says. As agents learn more and take on more, they become more valuable. If the price is frozen, he asks, "what happens to the supply?" His answer is that it goes away, because the provider can't pay experienced agents what they're now worth without absorbing the difference.
That's the whole mechanism. The core of a per-agent price is the agent's salary, so when the price stays frozen past year one, Ciniero says, the call center protects it by churning out its best people.
The core of a per-agent price is the agent's salary, so when the price stays frozen past year one, Ciniero says, the call center protects it by churning out its best people.
Ciniero calls the pressure margin creep, and he argues nobody comes out ahead. Losing a proven agent is expensive for the provider, and a brand-new hire carries more risk than one who has done strong work for a year. The client keeps paying the same rate for a less experienced team, one the provider keeps refilling with cheaper replacements.
His advice to clients tempted to hold the line is two words: "Don't do that." In his view the arrangement is bad for the client's business and hard on the call center. His warning is that the client may also lose its own customers to a competitor whose support provider "does it right."
His reframing is the part worth bringing into a budget meeting. What a client reads as wage inflation or cost creep, Ciniero argues, is really the cost of developing the best people. In his view, that produces happier customers and better results than a service with churn built into its pricing.
A flat-fee lesson from bookkeeping
The same problem shows up wherever a fixed fee meets work that changes. Lynn Talbot, who ran a bookkeeping firm for more than a decade and now coaches bookkeepers, described the supplier's side of it in an October 14 episode of The Better Bookkeeper Show. Her flat-fee clients added bank accounts, employees and payroll needs, and called with more questions, while their monthly fees stayed the same.
For a long stretch she simply absorbed it, in what she calls her minimizing phase. Her staff would flag extra hours on a client's timesheet, and she would wave them through, telling herself next month would balance out or that faster software would win the time back. It didn't, and she says the habit cost her firm thousands in lost profit.
That phase is the supplier-side mirror of a frozen call center rate. A provider can quietly absorb the gap for a while, but the cost lands somewhere. For Talbot it landed in her margins; in Ciniero's account, a call center pays it by letting its experienced agents go.
Her fix started with data. She pulled a year of revenue by client, then the last three months to see which way it was trending, subtracted merchant service fees, and compared the result with job-costed staff time from time tracking. Hourly work was easy to read: she paid staff $25 an hour and billed clients $75. The flat-rate clients were where margins had slipped, so she compared them with long-term clients who were priced where she wanted them.
Then she raised prices for dozens of clients. She expected 10 to 20% of them to leave, and none did in the first round. She puts that down to knowing the numbers and explaining plainly how each client's business had changed. Her own summary of the principle: "Your clients are allowed to grow. But your scope and your pricing need to grow with them."
Two cautions keep this from being a universal rule. Both accounts come from the supplier's side of the table, and Ciniero's argument is also part of how his own firm wins business, so buyers should check it against their own data on agent tenure and service quality. Talbot's result comes from one firm in a different industry. It suggests an increase backed by documented data lands better than one with no explanation, which is a narrower claim than saying clients always accept raises.
The argument matters most for programs where customers can tell experienced agents from new ones, the situation Ciniero describes in the honeymoon year. Where the work is simple enough that a new hire performs close to a veteran, a buyer could reasonably decide the trade-off is acceptable.
Questions to settle before signing
Telecom Reseller's conclusion is that telecom providers and other companies outsourcing support should raise this when a contract is first discussed. Four questions, offered here as editorial guidance rather than an industry requirement, put the issue on the table early:
- How much of the per-agent rate is salary, and how much is taxes, benefits and workspace overhead?
- What is the provider's review cycle, and how does an approved raise reach the billed rate?
- What do agent tenure and turnover look like on comparable accounts after the first year?
- Which written assumptions, such as the skill level the role requires, would trigger a rate review if they change?
For that last question, a borrowed habit from project management helps. TeamGantt's guide to scope creep separates unreviewed additions from an approved change, which goes through review and gets built into the plan, and it treats written-down assumptions as a documented reason to revisit the plan when they turn out wrong. The core of its change process is simple: capture the request in writing, assess the effect on cost and workload, decide with the approver and record the result.
Applied to an agent contract, the idea is modest. A year-one raise is about as predictable as a change gets, which makes it easier than most to write into a contract in advance, so it arrives as a reviewed, priced change rather than a margin squeeze.
If the proposed rate has no way to absorb raises, ask the provider directly how it plans to keep the account's top performers past month 12.
The signal is easy to spot in the next RFP or renewal: does the provider's quote include a raise mechanism at all? By Ciniero's logic, a quote without one has already decided what happens to the rock stars in month 13.
Sources
Featured companies
Your experts belong here
Every story in MarketScale Business Services starts with a company putting its consultants, practice leads, and account teams on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.
Clients hire the firm whose thinking they have already read, which means fewer cold conversations for your partners.
About the author
The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.