Skip to content
MarketScale
‹ Back to IndustriesRetail

Best Practices for Returns

This episode of Keeping Count features Herb Billings, VP of Product Strategy at Datascan. Free returns are now the norm, and Billings notes, “Retailers need to consider them as part of the purchase process, not something separate.” The return policy of a store, if done well, can win the company a customer for life. If…

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Retail teams put it to work with Sales Enablement.

Promoted content from Datascan on MarketScale.

Share

Get featured

Want to get featured in MarketScale Retail?

Create a free MarketScale workspace and get your company's expertise featured across our Retail coverage. No credit card, no demo required.

Start free

This episode of Keeping Count features Herb Billings, VP of Product Strategy at Datascan.

Free returns are now the norm, and Billings notes, “Retailers need to consider them as part of the purchase process, not something separate.” The return policy of a store, if done well, can win the company a customer for life. If not, they’ll shop somewhere else.

What’s the best customer-centric approach to returns? Billings explained, “First, it’s important to say that two-thirds of online shoppers research return policies before purchasing. It needs to be easy to read and obvious. It also should be easy to find through the navigation of the website and app.”

Billings urges retailers to make it painless. “Include a prepaid shipping label for returns where appropriate. You want to gather as much information as you can to improve the process, but make it easy for the consumer.”

As to where customers should make returns, it’s about convenience. “It’s whatever is the easiest for them, which could be shipping it back or returning it to a physical location, even if the item isn’t sold there,” Billings added.

Retailers can make or break customer relationships with returns. “Your best shoppers are often ones with high return rates, so treat them well. If you attempt to minimize returns, you’ll also minimize your customers.”

Video TranscriptExpand ↓

Hello, everyone, welcome back to Herb's hot takes, we're continuing a series here on herbs outtakes talking about returns, so we've outlined the problem of returns over the past two episodes. We talked about how they're growing in size, the impact of online as well, and then talked a little bit more just about what happens to returns once they've actually been given back to the retailer. And so today we're outlining best practices, and joining me once again is her Billings, the VP of technology strategy at data scan. Welcome back to The show. How are you? I'm doing great today. Tyler, how are you? I am doing well. I'm excited to talk best practices today and get into some solutions when it comes to returns. I think this is an exciting topic, and I'm ready to dive in. Yes, certainly we've talked about problems. So far. Now what the heck do we do about them? And that's the exciting part. You know, just sort of a recap. The early online Sellers are what forced retail to evolve to offer free and easy returns. You mentioned Zappos in a previous episode. Yes, they were one. They've been bought by Amazon, of course, and Amazon has continued the free and easy return process. Gone are the days of the disincentives to return items so that, you know, now it's a very easy process. Everybody's expecting that. Given that some categories experience between 30% and 40% returns, it should be thought of as an integral part of the purchase process, not just some separate process that you have to think about, that you have to finish up before you can say that we are an omnichannel retailer. If you get this returns process right from the consumer's perspective, you will have a customer for life. If you get it wrong, I'll shop at another retailer. It's a great point. So as we think about this process and what it looks like and how to make it a customer centric approach to returns, what's the first step in that process? Yes well, it's really good to understand that 2/3 of online shoppers research the returns policy prior to making their purchase. Wow so with that understood that policy needs to be easy to read, it must be intuitively obvious to the reader, or it's going to be too cumbersome. They'll shop elsewhere. It should have no ifs, ands, or buts. To me, that complex is up any wording. Simplifying is hard. If it's not an all always returnable product, then making that a simple thing to understand is very, very difficult. The next thing it needs to be as easy to find. Again, back to the 2/3 of shoppers review the policy. First, they need to be able to find it if they can't find it again. There's going to be another website with a similar or identical item that they can buy. It needs to be throughout the navigation on the website or the app easy to find from the home page if they first get there on the details page, if that's when they think about it. Certainly in the cart before they commit and then on the receipt. Absolutely so once that returns decision has been made that the consumer has decided, OK, I'm returning this item. And we've talked about the returns policy. What happens next? What's the next step? Well, certainly once that decision has been made to return it, it needs to be painless. And you'll hear me say painless a lot. You need to start with the online portal. So wherever they purchased it, that needs to be certainly a good starting point for where to return it. Include a pre-paid shipping label with the shipment, if appropriate. If not, enable them to download one from the site. Gather as much information as you can to feed your analytics process. So that you can continuously improve your returns, but you don't want that information gathering to be burdensome. If it's difficult, the customer is going to pencil, whip it and just answer whatever is the first answer in your list, and you won't get good, good information from that. So when we talk about consumer expectations, where are people expecting to be engaging in returns or are people expecting to go into a store? Or are they expecting to be able to ship it back? Give us a little bit of insight there on what the consumer expectations are for location. The consumers are interested in the easiest possible return, so it depends upon size. It depends upon the item, it depends upon how many they have. You need to allow them to ship it back. But more and more the retailers are accepting returns in their brick and mortar stores, regardless of where the item was purchased. Even if that item is not normally for sale in the brick and mortar store, customers are now able to return it to that store. That works really well for the MacY's, the Penney's, the Nordstrom's of the world. But what if you're an online business and you don't actually have brick and mortar locations? You can partner with one of these returns companies that facilitate returns primarily for online retail, but also other brick and mortar retailers with limited footprints. They can accept at, say, every staples store. So it's an easy you're running an errand. You drop into the Staples. You drop it off and it's handled from there. Whatever is the easiest process is what you want to do. Another thing sort of related to that. How many times have we tried to return something and try to get it exactly the way it looked when it came in? I'm thinking of a shirt with pins in it. Yes and you try to fold it up and get the exact creases and get those pins in the right spot. Package list returns are something that's, you know, getting attention in the retail industry where you just take the item. You doesn't matter whether you have the plastic or the box or the pens or whatever it came in, you just return it. And that's another way to make it even less painful. Offer a full refund. People are typically fine with store credits if it's a brick and mortar purchase. Online purchases. Refunds are the norm. what impact has the pandemic had on the world of returns and what consumers expect from returns? Well, the pandemic certainly has impacted returns. They take longer to process now because they have to be cleaned. But from the consumer's perspective, and the best practice seems to be going in the direction of contactless returns, where the consumer drops it off and does not. The store associate doesn't have to handle it and there's much less contact involved. Well, I've enjoyed talking about some solutions here today here on the third episode of our series here on returns. Tie a bow on it for us. Give us a summary of what we've discussed here today. Sure, Tyler. One thing to make sure everybody knows in the retail world that your best shoppers are often the ones with the highest return rate, so it's important to take care of them. You make a difficult process specifically to minimize the returns that you have to deal with, and you will also be minimizing the number of customers you have to deal with. And that's a bad thing. In-store returns are really should be viewed as an opportunity to convert an online buyer. That might be somebody who hasn't shopped in your brick and mortar store before, and now they're returning an item there in the store, likely to buy something else. The process again needs to be easy and painless. The amount of investment you put into this will be a good return in the long run. So now that we've talked about some best practices for returns coming up in the next episode, we're going to be talking about how you can minimize returns in the first place. That's going to be an exciting episode you won't want to miss, but for this one, her Billings. Thanks for joining me once again. Thank you, Tyler. Absolutely And everyone, we'll see you on the next episode of herbs that takes.

Datascan

Part of this channel

Datascan

Barcode and RFID inventory counting solutions for global retailers

Visit the channel

Your experts belong here

Every story in MarketScale Retail starts with a company putting its merchandising leads, store operations teams, and category managers on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.

Category buyers trust operators, so your merchandising leads shorten the distance between first search and first call.

Get your team featuredSee how it works15 minutes, straight to a calendar.

Follow Retail Insights

Get new expert content in your inbox.

Retail: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Retail buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. Explore how your experts, customers, and partners can become useful content for buyers and AI search.

Free plan

You just read one Retail expert. Your company is full of them.

This article was produced through MarketScale. The same platform turns your merchandising leads, store operations teams, and category managers into the articles, video, and social content Retail buyers are searching for. Create a free workspace and see it with your own people. No credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What you get, free

Your own MarketScale workspace, up to 10 people
One professional video edit a month for qualifying companies
Media requests to your crowd, remote recording, AI writing tools
$0, no credit card, nothing that expires

More Retail Insights

Retail Refined with Woof Gang Bakery CEO Ricardo Azevedo

Retail Refined with Woof Gang Bakery CEO Ricardo Azevedo

Ricardo Azevedo, CEO of Woof Gang Bakery and Grooming, applies franchise expertise from Tim Hortons and Burger King to build a community-centered pet care brand. He attributes growth to the franchise model's balance of scale with neighborhood presence, rigorous training, and technology integration.

  • 01Pet care is integrating into wellness lifestyle as consumers view pet health as family well-being, driving industry growth even during economic downturns
  • 02Woof Gang plans to expand to 450 locations across North America by 2027 while maintaining local community character through the franchise model
  • 03Technology infrastructure for appointment scheduling and customer relationship management enables personalized service at scale

Sep 14, 2026

Fuel-selling convenience stores hit an eight-year high even as total count slips

Fuel-selling convenience stores hit an eight-year high even as total count slips

NACS and NIQ TDLinx put the 2026 U.S. convenience-store count at 151,975 locations, down 280 stores. Fuel-selling stores rose to 122,620, the highest in eight years. For operators, the data sharpens where forecourt uptime, fuel margins, and foodservice investments matter most by state and ownership scale.

  • 01A flat national store count can still mean more forecourts to run: fuel-selling locations grew 768 sites even as total c-stores fell 280, per NACS.
  • 02State variation is the real planning variable: Texas alone has 16,504 stores while Alaska has 185, and New York saw the biggest decline (-143), per NACS.
  • 03Ownership mix drives vendor go-to-market: 63% of stores sit with operators at 10 or fewer locations, a reminder that ‘enterprise’ rollouts must work for small fleets too, per NACS.

Sep 13, 2026

Retail Refined Podcast - Sali Christeson

Retail Refined Podcast - Sali Christeson

Sali Christeson, CEO and founder of Argent, discussed her journey from banking and tech into fashion on MarketScale's Retail Refined podcast. She founded Argent to address the gap in professional workwear for women, combining bold, functional designs with a community-building mission to support career advancement.

  • 01A 2015 study showed Sali that clothing significantly affects women's professional perception, motivating her to launch Argent in response to the fashion industry's neglect of working women.
  • 02Argent's mission extends beyond apparel to community building, connecting professional women across industries to foster mentorships and resources for career advancement.
  • 03Argent is expanding direct online channels while innovating physical retail experiences to evolve workwear solutions for shifting professional needs.

Sep 8, 2026

Explore More Retail Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Retail.

Browse Retail Hub

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Retail and beyond.

Book a 15-minute demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512