Skip to content
‹ Back to IndustriesBusiness Services

Fraud rings now operate like a business—and one-time onboarding checks aren’t enough

Mitek’s Adam Basia and M&T Bank financial-crimes SVP Karen Boyer say on the Fraud and Focus podcast that fraud has become a repeatable business at scale, with Telegram lowering barriers to entry. Boyer recounts how a prior bank spotted synthetic “sleeper” accounts in 2020 and later saw them funnel EIDL relief funds. They argue banks need identity authentication and continuous transaction monitoring beyond one-time onboarding checks.

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Business Services teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.

By MarketScale Newsroom · · Mitek SystemsM&t BankFraud PreventionIdentity Verification
Share
Listen to the audio brief

Key facts, context, and what it means.

AUDIO
0:00—

Key takeaways

01

Synthetic sleeper accounts opened before the pandemic were later used to funnel EIDL relief funds, so a clean opening period no longer proves an account is legitimate.

02

Check fraud has moved from washing one paper check to digitizing a genuine check and depositing the template at multiple banks; the check is real, so the activity around it is the only tell.

03

A face-morphed video call can now match a fake ID, which pushes banks from verifying data to authenticating the person typing it and monitoring transactions for the life of the account.

Free workspace

Turn your Business Services expertise into content.

Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.

Try it Free

Karen Boyer spends part of her week in industry groups, IFCI, BPI and the ABA among them, and she was careful to say on Mitek Systems' Fraud and Focus podcast that she was describing what those groups see across the industry, not what any one bank sees. What they see is a criminal trade with no entry requirements. A fraudster once had to find a dark net forum and get another criminal to vouch for them, Boyer, senior vice president of financial crimes at M&T Bank, told host Adam Basia, who leads product marketing at Mitek.

But now it's just at scale, I just have to download Telegram, and I'm part of it now. — Karen Boyer, Senior Vice President, Financial Crimes, M&T Bank

That change ties together what Basia calls the four horsemen: deepfakes, data breaches, template attacks and injection attacks. Each is a separate problem. Together, Boyer and Basia argue, they turn fraud into a business that is tested, refined and resold, and that a one-time onboarding check was never built to stop.

Check cooking shows how a single hit becomes a run

Basia points to check fraud, which he said has occupied Mitek for a large share of its history, as the clearest example. Check washing meant stealing one paper check, lifting the ink and getting one attempt. Now, he said, a criminal photographs the check, builds a template and deposits the same image at multiple institutions, altering it slightly after each success.

Boyer corrected him on one point: the deposits do not just get attempted, they clear. The check itself is genuine, taken from stolen mail, so the counterfeit-detection work banks spent years building around check stock has nothing to flag. What gives the scheme away is the activity around the check, she said, and regulations written for paper originals have not caught up with the technology.

For a payments or operations leader the lesson is uncomfortable. A control that goes quiet is not a control that is finished. Basia compared fraudsters to water that always finds the path of least resistance, and said the industry never gets to drop a defense, only add to it.

A fake ID and a face morph beat the front door

Deepfakes get the headlines because they are visual, Basia said. Boyer said the threat is neither overstated nor fearmongering, and it predates the generative AI news cycle. In her investigator days, one question to a scam victim, whether they had ever met the person, was often enough to break the spell. Today victims answer that they FaceTime the person every day, and some of those faces are morphed to match a fake profile.

The same tools hit onboarding, where the bank has no history on the applicant at all.

But I can generate a fake ID online for $3.95. I can use a quick tool like Magic Cam or something else to face morph myself to look like whatever person is on that ID. — Adam Basia, Product Marketing Lead, Mitek Systems

Adaptive Security, a security awareness training vendor, describes on its own site a January 2024 case in which a finance worker at an engineering firm authorized $25.6 million in wire transfers to accounts controlled by AI-generated impersonators, on a video call where every other participant was a deepfake. The same material lists identity verification and know-your-customer systems as under pressure from AI-generated documents, synthetic identities and digital injection attacks. It is marketing for a training product and carries the vendor's interest, but the case it cites is dated and specific.

Boyer said the onboarding problem is spreading past banks into underwriting, title companies and real estate, and into hiring, where employers are discovering that applicants can pretend to be other people. Basia added that the branch deserves attention. A teller in Austin, Texas has no way to know what a Minnesota driver's license should look like, he said, and the digital defenses banks built in 2020 did not follow customers into the branch, which can make it easier to open a mule account in person.

Sleeper accounts waited for a pandemic that had not started yet

Every synthetic identity starts with something real, Basia said: stolen personal data from breaches, of which there is now no shortage. He asked whether that reality has changed how Boyer views trust at onboarding. Her answer was that it has not, because her career has run on guilty until proven innocent, but the bar for proof has moved.

A decade ago, matching an application's data to identity verification records counted for something, because the applicant had to know all of it. Now, Boyer said, that step proves little on its own. The work shifts to what she calls identity authentication, proving that the person typing Adam's information is Adam, with other digital signals doing the same job.

The long game is where the damage hides. At a bank where she worked previously, Boyer said, her team spotted synthetic sleeper accounts in 2020 and watched them in what she described as a honeypot. When EIDL pandemic relief arrived, the accounts began funneling government funds, even though they had been opened before the pandemic existed, farmed and seasoned for a bust-out whose target the fraudsters had not yet chosen.

Basia said he sees the same pattern: accounts built quietly to accumulate credit, then busted out, sold on Telegram or turned to money laundering. Boyer said the seasoning and the bust-out are often done by different people, with the account changing hands in between. Credit monitoring catches little of this, she said, and identity theft with no credit component at all, such as a stolen identity carrying a heroin-trafficking warrant, stays under the radar.

One gap at one bank becomes a flood everywhere

Template attacks give the model its scale. Once a ring finds a document type or application pattern that passes at one institution, Basia said, it repeats it thousands of times and moves to the next. He asked whether the past two years feel like a shift from isolated attacks to something industrialized.

And it's almost like the new phishing where it's okay. Well, I'm gonna send a thousand emails out. And if I get 10 people to answer, that's still a good day. — Karen Boyer, Senior Vice President, Financial Crimes, M&T Bank

Boyer offered a hypothetical, with her usual disclaimer that she has no inside knowledge of any bank's controls: a ring learns that one bank accepts passport cards its document check handles poorly, floods it, then scouts for other banks using the same vendor. The consequence for a fraud or risk executive is that onboarding cannot be treated as a gate, she said. It has to be one input into monitoring that runs for the life of the account.

That's why you also can't just trust the onboarding and you have to have the continuous monitoring of the transactions. And that's how you're going to find the root cause of what might be the broken control of the onboarding. — Karen Boyer, Senior Vice President, Financial Crimes, M&T Bank

The old rule of thumb that a bad account reveals itself within a few months of opening no longer holds for sophisticated schemes, she said. Losses have to be reviewed at scale, not one by one, to find the shared feature that traces back to a broken control at application time. Basia said fraud defense is by nature a little reactive: the first sighting of a new tactic is usually a loss, and the job then is to search the book for everything that resembles it before it breaks out.

Injection attacks arrive looking like normal traffic

The fourth horseman used to seem technical even to him, Basia said. Free virtual cameras and online tutorial libraries now let someone with a decent laptop push content straight into a verification system in minutes. Boyer's response was blunt: a well-executed injection attack does not look like an attack, it looks like ordinary activity, so the industry is less sure how much it is seeing than how much it is missing.

That is the practical question for a bank or fintech buying identity tooling, and for the CFO signing off on it. Basia's warning is that nothing gets retired, since check fraud returned once the industry assumed it was solved. Boyer's signal is more specific: when losses examined together share a document type, a channel or a vendor path that dates to onboarding, that commonality is the broken control, and a ring is already testing it at the next bank.

Featured companies

Your experts belong here

Every story in MarketScale Business Services starts with a company putting its consultants, practice leads, and account teams on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.

Clients hire the firm whose thinking they have already read, which means fewer cold conversations for your partners.

Book DemoSee how it works15 minutes, straight to a calendar.

About the author

MarketScale Newsroom
MarketScale NewsroomEditorial Team, MarketScale

The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.

B2B Weekly

The week in Business Services, and sixteen other industries, every Monday.

Ten stories, one-line takes, five minutes. Free.

Business Services: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Business Services buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. Explore how your experts, customers, and partners can become useful content for buyers and AI search.

Free Trial

You just read one Business Services expert. Your company is full of them.

This article was produced through MarketScale. The same platform turns your consultants, practice leads, and account teams into the articles, video, and social content Business Services buyers are searching for. Start a free trial and see it with your own people. For qualifying companies, no credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What your free trial includes

Hands-on access to the MarketScale platform
Media requests to your crowd, remote recording, AI writing tools
No demo required. No credit card.
For qualifying companies. Company confirmation required.

More Business Services Insights

The Early Scale: McKinsey finds Physical AI value shifting to deployment

The Early Scale: McKinsey finds Physical AI value shifting to deployment

AI's influence is redefining operational landscapes across sectors, from industrial IoT to healthcare. McKinsey notes a shift in physical AI, with value moving from robot hardware to deployment. This trend underlines the increasing significance of application over machinery in realizing AI's full potential. Concurrently, Zoom's healthcare investments highlight AI's role in enhancing virtual care, reflecting broader shifts toward more integrated tech solutions in healthcare. Meanwhile, discussions around AI-driven educational tools, such as Penn State's AI tutors, indicate both potential benefits and implementation challenges, especially in educational settings.

  • 01McKinsey expects physical AI value to shift toward deployment and field service efficiencies, not hardware, as robotics received most of the $38 billion in robotics funding.
  • 02A Penn State study found 21 of 119 AI tutor chat sessions didn’t encourage students to apply reasoning to homework, raising questions about AI’s current effectiveness in educational settings.
  • 03Zoom Ventures invested in Medaica to integrate FDA-cleared devices like the M1 stethoscope into telehealth for real-time monitoring during video visits.

Nov 22, 2026

AI-native brokerages bring in nearly $1 million per employee in Zywave report

AI-native brokerages bring in nearly $1 million per employee in Zywave report

A new Zywave study puts AI-native brokerages at close to $1 million in revenue per employee, versus about $175,000 at traditional agencies. Zywave’s data points to the back office as a key source of the gap, even as producer roles grow. It also argues cleaner, automated data can affect carrier bonus commissions, which run from 0.43% to 6.74% of premium on one published schedule.

  • 01When a carrier bonus can swing fifteenfold on loss ratio alone, the data work that trims an agency’s back office can also influence the size of its contingent or bonus check—especially if it helps keep the book in better loss-ratio tiers.
  • 02Revenue per employee is the planning number to track: about $175,000 at traditional agencies and close to $1 million at AI-native brokerages, while P&C headcount grows by less than 1% a year.
  • 03Survey adoption overstates readiness. Nearly three-quarters of brokerages report some AI use, but only 13% use it across multiple parts of the business.

Nov 21, 2026

The Early Scale: FDA's fortification policy shakes up functional food sector

The Early Scale: FDA's fortification policy shakes up functional food sector

The landscape of B2B industries is shifting as new technologies and initiatives reshape strategies. From sustainable packaging initiatives in healthcare to a major USDA grant expanding ag-tech education, the intersection of technology and sustainability stands out. The article also highlights FedRAMP as a key compliance framework for cloud providers serving federal agencies—signaling that adaptation and innovation remain essential.

  • 01FDA fortification policy does not set federal guidelines for creatine, caffeine, and fiber, allowing brand teams to make independent fortification decisions.
  • 02Capsa Healthcare's RoboPharma HV Wall is compatible with Parcel Health's Tully Tube paper vials, enabling sustainable, automated pharmacy operations.
  • 03Iowa State University received a $6 million USDA grant to develop agricultural tech education through its FIELD Commons program.

Nov 21, 2026

Explore More Business Services Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Business Services.

Browse Business Services Hub

About the Experts

MarketScale Newsroom
MarketScale Newsroom

Editorial Team

MarketScale

The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.

KB
Karen Boyer

M&T Bank

AB
Adam Basia

Mitek

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Business Services and beyond.

Book a Demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512