Skip to content
‹ Back to IndustriesBusiness Services

95% of enterprise AI pilots deliver no measurable ROI, and the fix isn't more tools

A study from MIT reports that 95% of enterprise AI pilots do not yield measurable ROI. This suggests that the problem lies in structural issues rather than the need for more tools. Resolving these fundamental issues is crucial for enhancing the effectiveness of AI deployments.

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Business Services teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.

By MarketScale Newsroom · Ai AdoptionEnterprise AiGenerative AiAi Governance
Share
Listen to the audio brief

Key facts, context, and what it means.

AUDIO
0:00—
95% of enterprise AI pilots deliver no measurable ROI, and the fix isn't more tools

Key takeaways

01

95% of enterprise AI pilots fail to yield a measurable return on investment.

02

The lack of ROI from AI projects is primarily due to underlying structural issues.

03

Addressing foundational problems is necessary for successful AI implementation.

Free workspace

Turn your Business Services expertise into content.

Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.

Try it Free

Ninety-five percent of generative AI pilots at major enterprises have delivered no measurable impact on the bottom line. That is the finding from MIT's Project NANDA, reported by Fortune, and it is the number that should be pinned above every AI steering committee agenda in 2026. After two-plus years of aggressive tool rollouts, most organizations have faster individuals and unchanged organizations.

The failure is not the models. It is the architecture underneath them. According to a Smartsheet analysis published via Axios in July 2026, enterprises have systematically confused two very different things: ad hoc intelligence, which makes a single employee quicker at a task, and institutional intelligence, which makes the entire organization smarter over time. They built the first and called it transformation.

A structural debt, now overdue

For years, fragmented enterprise software stacks were held together by people. Workers knew which SharePoint folder was actually current, which Slack thread overrode the formal policy document, and which approval had already been given verbally. That human connective tissue papered over real architectural gaps. AI cannot replicate it, because AI needs connected, governed context to be useful, and most enterprise stacks do not provide that.

Smartsheet's Chief AI Officer Drew Garner framed the problem directly in the Axios piece: individual task completion has gotten easier, but working across systems and across teams has not improved. The fragmented stack was always a liability, and AI deployment has made that liability impossible to ignore.

AI didn't create the fragmentation problem in enterprise stacks, it just made the cost of ignoring it impossible to defer.

The compounding consequence is visible at the employee level right now. Workers are already routing company work through consumer AI tools, with or without IT authorization, according to the Axios report. Those tools have no way to distinguish a current approved document from a stale draft, or to enforce what a given user is actually permitted to see. The result is a governance gap that widens every week AI adoption grows.

Two failure modes hiding inside the productivity narrative

The Smartsheet analysis names two employee archetypes that enterprise leaders are almost certainly recognizing on their own teams. The first is the productivity hoarder: someone who quietly masters AI prompting, ships work at twice the previous speed, and shares nothing. That private capability is a single point of failure. When the person takes leave or resigns, the speed advantage leaves with them, and no organizational knowledge was ever captured.

The second archetype is what Smartsheet calls the "slop cannon": an employee who mistakes volume for value and uses AI to generate enormous quantities of output with no improvement in quality or relevance. Both behaviors share a root cause. When AI is deployed without governance, without a shared standard for what is true or what constitutes good output, individual tools amplify whatever habits already exist rather than elevating the organization.

Workvivo's analysis of AI adoption patterns echoes the same diagnosis: companies have spent heavily on AI tooling but have not addressed the implementation gaps that prevent those tools from producing organizational change. The gap between AI arrival and enterprise transformation is not a technology problem. It is a process and architecture problem.

The three layers most AI deployments skip

According to the Smartsheet framework, moving past the 95% wall requires capturing three categories of knowledge that have historically lived only in employees' heads. The first is context: a live, connected map of what work exists, who owns it, and what its current state is across every system. The second is intent: a clear picture of what outcomes actually matter, and early signals when execution is drifting away from the plan. The third is judgment: the decision frameworks carried by experienced leaders that determine when to escalate, when to wait, and when the formal policy points the wrong direction.

Most AI deployments skip all three. Without them, AI cannot compound its value. Every project that ends and every team that reorganizes resets the system back to zero, because the organizational knowledge was never encoded anywhere a machine could use it.

The practical implication for procurement and IT leaders evaluating AI platforms is significant. A tool that makes a single workflow faster is easy to demo and nearly impossible to justify at enterprise scale. A platform that connects to a governed, current, permissioned view of organizational work, and that leaves an auditable trail on every action, is harder to stand up but is the only architecture that produces the 5% outcome MIT identified.

What the 5% are doing differently

The organizations that have cleared the productivity wall share a common approach, according to the Axios report. Rather than accepting the false choice between locking AI down entirely or opening it up without controls, they have connected AI to a governed operational picture where every data read is scoped to the person asking and every action generates an auditable record. That is not a feature of any single AI model. It is a property of the underlying platform.

Smartsheet is positioning its work management platform as that governed layer, arguing that AI agents need a structured, permissioned workspace to act reliably rather than a raw connection to an undifferentiated data lake. The broader market signal is clear regardless of vendor: the enterprise AI investment that matters in 2026 is not the model or the chat interface sitting on top of it. It is the data architecture, the governance standard, and the workflow connective tissue underneath.

MIT's Project NANDA finding, that only 1 in 20 enterprise AI pilots reaches measurable ROI, puts a hard number on what many operations leaders have been sensing for months. The next procurement decision for most organizations should not be which large language model to license. It should be whether the platform running underneath that model actually knows what is true, what is current, and who is allowed to ask.

Featured companies

Your experts belong here

Every story in MarketScale Business Services starts with a company putting its consultants, practice leads, and account teams on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.

Clients hire the firm whose thinking they have already read, which means fewer cold conversations for your partners.

Book DemoSee how it works15 minutes, straight to a calendar.

About the author

MarketScale Newsroom
MarketScale NewsroomEditorial Team, MarketScale

The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.

B2B Weekly

The week in Business Services, and sixteen other industries, every Monday.

Ten stories, one-line takes, five minutes. Free.

Business Services: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Business Services buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. Explore how your experts, customers, and partners can become useful content for buyers and AI search.

Free Trial

You just read one Business Services expert. Your company is full of them.

This article was produced through MarketScale. The same platform turns your consultants, practice leads, and account teams into the articles, video, and social content Business Services buyers are searching for. Start a free trial and see it with your own people. For qualifying companies, no credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What your free trial includes

Hands-on access to the MarketScale platform
Media requests to your crowd, remote recording, AI writing tools
No demo required. No credit card.
For qualifying companies. Company confirmation required.

More Business Services Insights

Why law firms' next AI edge may come from how they manage change

Why law firms' next AI edge may come from how they manage change

Harvey and Legora launched AI tools both named Intake about a day apart in October 2026. Matching tools is easy. The more lasting law firm edge is likely the internal change work that makes AI show up as faster work and lower or more predictable outside counsel spend—outcomes in-house clients will notice on their bills.

  • 01When two vendors can ship products with the same name about a day apart, the difference a client can see is whether the work, and the invoice, changed afterward.
  • 02Over 85% of surveyed Association of Corporate Counsel members say they have embedded AI in their own legal departments, so the buyers reading law firm AI announcements can judge them from experience.
  • 03A useful test before any AI rollout: can leadership name the problem being solved, who the change affects, and who has the time and skill to make it stick?

Nov 15, 2026

The Early Scale: Lilly unlocks $3.5B plant for future obesity drugs

The Early Scale: Lilly unlocks $3.5B plant for future obesity drugs

This article highlights several notable B2B moves: Eli Lilly’s planned $3.5B injectables facility in Pennsylvania tied to its broader U.S. manufacturing commitment, JD Sports’ rapid RFID rollout across UK and Ireland stores that lifted on-shelf availability to 98%, and Celliaz’s gene-therapy effort for retinitis pigmentosa in partnership with Andelyn Biosciences—plus a look at new AI tools in accounts payable and freight tendering.

  • 01Eli Lilly is investing $3.5 billion in a new injectables facility in Pennsylvania to support next-generation treatments, including an obesity drug candidate.
  • 02Eli Lilly’s $3.5B injectables facility signals a major push in U.S. drug manufacturing.
  • 03Lilly is positioning its new injectables facility to support next-generation treatments, including an obesity drug candidate in Phase 3.

Nov 15, 2026

Deloitte's $2.4 trillion retail estimate puts private capital's back office to the test

Deloitte's $2.4 trillion retail estimate puts private capital's back office to the test

Deloitte’s inaugural 2027 Private Capital Outlook argues private capital is increasingly shared across banks, private credit firms and insurers, raising hard questions about who keeps the economics, controls the data, owns the client and stays accountable for risk. It also describes a possible jump in US retail involvement—from about $80 billion to $2.4 trillion—making valuation, liquidity terms, reporting and servicing central operational issues.

  • 01US retail participation in private capital could rise sharply—by Deloitte’s arithmetic, a possible thirtyfold increase from about $80B to $2.4T—bringing tougher questions on valuation, liquidity/redemptions, reporting and client service that fall heavily on operations.
  • 02In Deloitte’s illustrative review of 18 disclosed ties among large US managers, 10 of 11 insurer partnerships included an equity stake, ownership interest or jointly capitalized platform, while bank partnerships leaned toward origination and distribution—suggesting different asks in insurer vs bank arrangements.
  • 03A semi-liquid wrapper can widen the door to private markets; it cannot change how long the asset underneath takes to pay back.

Nov 14, 2026

Explore More Business Services Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Business Services.

Browse Business Services Hub

About the Expert

MarketScale Newsroom
MarketScale Newsroom

Editorial Team

MarketScale

The MarketScale Newsroom reports on the companies, technologies, and trends shaping 16 B2B industries. It turns primary sources and expert commentary into clear, useful coverage for the people doing the work.

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Business Services and beyond.

Book a Demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512