# Bain: 41% of the biggest US fleets would change truck brands to save money

By MarketScale Newsroom · Published 2026-11-17 · Transportation on MarketScale
Canonical: https://www.marketscale.com/industries/transportation/bain-41-of-the-biggest-us-fleets-would-change-truck-brands-to-save-money

> Bain's 2026 US Truck Study: 79% of fleets expect growth, and 41% of the largest would switch truck makers for better per-mile economics.

## Key points

- Good satisfaction scores don't protect a truck maker: 41% of the largest US fleets would switch brands for better economics, even as the same makers post high Net Promoter Scores.
- The 49% of operators who see electric trucks matching diesel on cost are answering on the condition that charging is in place, and 67% openness to a Tesla Semi measures consideration, which typically runs well ahead of purchase intent.

More than a third of US truck fleet operators told Bain & Company they would leave their current truck maker if a rival offered better economics. Among the largest, most sophisticated fleets, the share rises to 41%.

Those answers come from Bain's 2026 US Truck Study, a survey of 210 fleet operators written by partners Bob Brinckman and Joshua Hinkel with Ryan Morrissey. Logistics Management covered the findings on November 11, and Supply Chain Digital followed on November 16 in a piece by Nick Edstrom that adds comment from both partners. The most telling detail is in Bain's own text: the truck makers facing this risk include ones posting high Net Promoter Scores.

Fleets can love their truck brand and still leave it: Bain found high Net Promoter Scores sitting alongside 41% of the largest fleets saying they would switch makers for better economics. That's an unusual position for the fleet director or procurement lead placing orders this winter. Strong demand normally favors the seller. Soft loyalty favors the buyer. This cycle has both.

## A buying wave with loose brand ties

Demand is strong. Bain found that 79% of operators expect their fleets to grow over the next 12 months, and more than a third expect growth of 10% or more. Bain names three main drivers: high fuel prices, recovering freight demand and aging fleets. Logistics Management reported the headline figure as nearly 80% of fleets planning major truck investments over the next six to 12 months.

Block Field

Bain's chart asks how operators expect truck demand in their own segment to change. Adding the three growth bands gives the 79% headline, and the top two bands together come to 37%, the group expecting gains of 10% or more.

Bain's lesson for truck makers is short: "availability wins." It draws that from the last upcycle. The maker that can quote credible lead times and then deliver on them takes share. Fleets told Bain much the same thing from the buyer's side: faster lead times and clearer pricing would win their business.

Taken together, those findings give purchasing teams a clear approach for this cycle. Truck makers are being told to fix lead times and pricing transparency, so dated delivery commitments and itemized pricing are fair terms to push for in quotes. And when more than a third of operators say they would switch, a competing quote is a credible option at the table. That is our reading of the data, not Bain's advice, and it applies most to fleets that buy enough trucks to move a maker's numbers.

## Fuel efficiency leads, ownership cost is climbing

Bain's purchase-criteria data answers two different questions, and they are easy to mix up. When operators were asked what matters most in a purchase, fuel efficiency came first at 45%, reliability and uptime second at 42%, and total cost of ownership third at 37%. Bain says that order matches its earlier studies. When they were asked which criteria had gained the most importance over the past three years, TCO moved up to share the top spot with fuel efficiency.

So TCO hasn't overtaken fuel efficiency in the ranking. It's the criterion gaining weight fastest. The rest of the survey shows why: 70% of operators name fuel prices as their top operating challenge, and nearly half report moderate or significant cost impacts from tariffs and trade policy over the past year. Supply Chain Digital adds that diesel has stayed above $4 a gallon in many markets.

One finding should worry incumbents: no truck maker earned an "excellent" fuel efficiency rating from the operators Bain surveyed. Bain says this "gas math" puts every maker's market share at risk. The lesson for buyers is narrower. If no maker scores excellent on the criterion buyers rank highest, fuel efficiency claims should be tested on the fleet's own routes before they decide a deal.

## Electric parity, with conditions attached

The electric numbers get quoted most, so the details matter. 49% of operators told Bain that electric trucks now match or beat diesel on TCO when enablers such as charging infrastructure are in place. Bain's summary goes further and says EVs have reached parity for most operators. The survey figure itself is just under half, and it comes with a condition.

Block Field

Bain doesn't expect those conditions to hold the market back for long. It says charging buildout takes time and parity varies by use case, but it calls those buffers temporary and says the industry is approaching a tipping point for select use cases.

Tesla is the reason Bain tells incumbents to act now. Bain notes that Tesla has a new, large semi factory, which Supply Chain Digital places in Nevada. 67% of operators said they would be open to buying a Tesla if enablers such as charging were in place. Bain says more than a quarter describe themselves as actively interested, and those buyers are concentrated in states like California and Texas.

Bain itself offers the strongest caution on that figure: considering a truck is different from planning to buy one, and the gap between the two is usually wide. The 67% shows how many sales conversations Tesla can open. Orders will be a smaller number. Bain also notes that the risk runs the opposite way from passenger cars. Carmakers, it argues, pushed EVs on customers before they were ready. Fleet operators are more economically driven buyers, and if the numbers work and charging exists, they may want to move faster than their suppliers.

## Where autonomy and batteries meet

73% of operators are evaluating how to use autonomous trucks, and interest is strongest among larger fleets. Many of the same operators are also interested in electric trucks. Bain finds the overlap strongest in Texas and California, where pilot activity is high, and on routes that suit both technologies: return-to-base runs, shorter routes and corridors with charging. Bain says this could point to a combined autonomous and electric push by a player like Tesla.

Block Field

Fleets mostly want proof that the technology works. Safety, reliability and liability top the list, and public perception barely registers at 5%. For a fleet safety director, that order suggests an autonomy pilot will be approved or rejected on validation data and insurance terms.

Bain argues trucking could adopt autonomy faster than passenger vehicles. Regional-haul routes repeat on well-known corridors, buyers decide on per-mile cost, and trucks spend much of their time in use, which makes each driverless hour worth more. Bain's comparison also lists factors that cut the other way. Trucks are heavy, travel fast and take longer to stop, so failures are more severe. Interstate operation can require several state or federal approvals.

Hinkel told Supply Chain Digital that large fleets are very interested in autonomy because of diesel and tariff costs, and that several are working to speed up their deployment timelines. He expects the largest fleets to move first because they can test specific routes and duty cycles and have better access to capital. If the economics hold, he said, some of the savings would pass through to freight customers, which could pull business away from smaller fleets that can't match the pricing.

How exposed a small carrier is depends on its lanes. Supply Chain Digital gives an example: a small fleet running fixed routes between two major Southern cities faces much higher risk than a last-mile operator in a large Northeast market, where autonomous trucks face more complex streets and more regulatory uncertainty. For shippers, the same logic suggests any price gap would show up first on repeatable regional lanes, so those contracts are the ones to benchmark.

## What would speed up adoption

Brinckman told Supply Chain Digital that Bain's base case is a steady adoption curve in line with history, varying a lot by use case. If early adopters show lower TCO through higher utilization, better safety and greater efficiency, he said, adoption could move much faster. Bain tells truck makers to watch for signs that adoption is speeding up or slowing down. Fleet buyers can watch for the same signs.

For fleets placing orders in this cycle, the data points to three checks:

1. Ask each truck maker for a dated delivery commitment and an itemized price, the two things fleets told Bain would win their business.
2. Model fuel efficiency and TCO on the fleet's own routes, since no maker earned an excellent fuel efficiency rating from the operators Bain surveyed.
3. Identify which lanes are return-to-base runs, short routes or corridors with charging. Bain sees electric and autonomous interest overlapping there, and early-adopter cost data would show up there first.

The number to watch is the first set of per-mile results that large fleets share from those lanes.

## Sources

- [Bain Sees Tesla Semi, Autonomy, Electric TCO Disrupt Fleets](https://supplychaindigital.com/news/bain-sees-tesla-semi-autonomy-electric-tco-disrupt-fleets)
- [Bain study notes that almost 80% of U.S. fleets plan major ...](https://www.logisticsmgmt.com/article/bain_study_notes_that_almost_80_of_u.s_fleets_plan_major_truck_investments) (Logistics Management)
- [2026 US Truck Study](https://www.bain.com/insights/2026-us-truck-study/)

Tags: Bain & Company, Tesla Semi, commercial trucking, fleet management, total cost of ownership, electric trucks, autonomous trucks, Class 8 trucks, fleet procurement, supply chain, logistics, OEM strategy

---
Source: MarketScale, https://www.marketscale.com/industries/transportation/bain-41-of-the-biggest-us-fleets-would-change-truck-brands-to-save-money. Published for AI indexing and citation; cite the canonical URL. Site guide for agents: https://www.marketscale.com/llms.txt
