# Why the NFL's newest helmet safety prize went to a liquid-filled chinstrap

By MarketScale Newsroom · Published 2026-11-18 · Sports & Entertainment on MarketScale
Canonical: https://www.marketscale.com/industries/sports-entertainment/why-the-nfls-newest-helmet-safety-prize-went-to-a-liquid-filled-chinstrap

> Facemask hits caused 44% of NFL in-game concussions last season. The league just funded a chinstrap built to soften them, with more facemask challenges coming.

## Key points

- Each gain in the helmet shell leaves the facemask holding a bigger share of what's left: facemask impacts accounted for 44% of NFL in-game concussions last season, up from 29% in 2015.
- A chinstrap protection claim such as 'up to 35% lower HARM' is a best-case lab figure; the useful question for any vendor is which metric, which impact locations and which helmet models it was tested on.
- The NFL plans more challenges aimed at redesigning the whole facemask area, and earlier HealthTECH grants ended in helmet models cleared for on-field use, so facemask performance could become a helmet buying criterion.

Forty-four percent. That's the share of NFL in-game concussions in the 2025 season that came from hits to the facemask, up from 29% in 2015. On Nov. 17 the league put money behind the part of the helmet that number points to, naming SoftShox and Guardian Sports joint winners of HealthTECH Challenge II for a chinstrap add-on filled with liquid shock absorbers.

The check is modest. The NFL's announcement puts the award at up to $100,000 in funding plus expert guidance to refine and produce the strap, and Sports Business Journal's Rob Schaefer described it as a $100,000 R&D grant. The bigger signal is where the money went. For the equipment manager or athletic director deciding what goes on a player's head, the award points to the facemask and chin as the next source of protection claims, and the place new products are likely to show up first.

## Why the facemask share keeps climbing

The NFL's explanation is about uneven progress. Over the past decade, the league says, helmet shell technology advanced at more than double the rate of improvements around the facemask. As a result, the share of concussions from shell impacts went down and the facemask's share went up.

Ann Bailey Good, a senior biomechanical engineer at Biocore who sat on the judging panel, told Sports Business Journal that this rise is why the challenge focused on the facemask. Her account matched the league's: years of work on shells and padding cut the share of concussions from those impacts, while the share involving the facemask kept growing.

Block Field

Read that number for what it is. It's a share of in-game concussions, not a count, and the NFL's release gives shares only. A share can climb even when the problem it measures holds steady, because the other slices are shrinking. Each gain in the helmet shell leaves the facemask holding a bigger share of what's left, and last season that share reached 44% of NFL in-game concussions.

The shell work paid off. The NFL notes that helmets in its Top-Performing category have a concussion rate nearly 30% lower on the field than helmets rated Not Recommended. The league wants to keep that gain while it works on the front of the helmet. Its stated goal for upcoming challenges is to hold the progress on shell impacts and make much larger gains in how the facemask absorbs energy.

## A shock absorber at the chin cup

The engineering idea is simple. When something hits the facemask, part of that force travels through the chin cup into the head. The Guardian SoftShox Chinstrap puts liquid-filled shock absorbers in that path to catch some of the force, and the NFL describes them as responding adaptively to the hit. SoftShox makes wearable hydraulic pads and equipment parts. Guardian Sports, founded in 2010, is the material science company behind the Guardian Cap.

That partner matters to buyers. The Guardian Cap is a soft padded layer that fits over an existing helmet, and Sports Business Journal reports it is worn in games by more than 30 NFL players this season and required in the league's contact practices. The chinstrap follows the same retrofit logic. It attaches to the helmet a player already wears and doesn't replace it, which puts it on the accessories line of an equipment budget instead of the helmet line.

The cap's own history shows how that kind of product spreads. Guardian Sports says the cap was first developed to reduce head impacts during football practice and has since moved into game-day use at all levels of play. The chinstrap starts further along that path, already in NFL games, though worn by a few players and not mandated anywhere. The company's catalog also runs well beyond football helmets, with a 5-STAR VT rated LOOP flag football headband, PEARL lacrosse balls and bio-based turf infill.

The strap is already beyond the prototype stage. The NFL says a few of its players wear it on the field. In August, a Guardian Sports release published by Athletic Business said Atlanta Falcons linebacker JD Bertrand had donated 50 Guardian Caps and 25 Guardian FLEX SoftShox chinstraps to Blessed Trinity Catholic High School in Roswell, Georgia. That release used the FLEX name, and it included the company's claim that the FLEX chinstrap cuts HARM, the Head Acceleration Response Metric, by up to 35%. That figure comes from Guardian Sports. The league's announcement describes how the strap works but publishes no performance number.

The same release called the FLEX the first and only safety-focused chinstrap designed to address a gap in helmet protection, which is also the company's own framing. The chinstrap has carried safety technology before, though for a different job. In June 2011, Coach & Athletic Director reported that Battle Sports Science's Impact Indicator, endorsed by Detroit Lions defensive tackle Ndamukong Suh, embedded sensors and proprietary software in a chinstrap to measure the G-force and duration of hits to the head and signal a possible head injury, so coaches and officials could pull a player for medical assessment.

That comparison is useful for buyers. The 2011 device read the hit after it happened; the SoftShox strap tries to take force out of it. A sensor is judged on whether it flags the right impacts, and an absorber on how much force it actually removes, which is why the metric behind any protection figure matters so much.

The league's own framing is the strongest reason not to overrate any single add-on. The NFL says real protection at the facemask will need a more systematic approach to designing the whole helmet. A chinstrap softens one route that force takes from the facemask to the head. The redesign the league describes would happen inside the helmet itself, and that's what the next round of challenges is meant to bring out.

## What earlier HealthTECH grants became

Earlier challenges show the path these awards tend to take. The NFL says earlier HealthTECH grants led to new helmet models that are now cleared for players to wear on the field. They also produced AI computer vision that helps detect helmet impacts, which fed directly into the league's Dynamic Kickoff rule change, along with machine-learning models that measure player contact and research into field surfaces. Grant money has ended up in equipment lists and in the rulebook.

Block Field

This round launched at Super Bowl LX and was run with Football Research, Inc. and Duke Biomedical Engineering. Duke BME and a panel it set up jointly with FRI judged the entries. The league describes the challenge as part of a broader commitment to raising the safety standard for all football helmets, not only those worn on Sundays.

Jeff Miller, the NFL executive vice president who oversees player health and safety, tied the result to the spending behind it. "The cutting-edge progress in helmet innovation is a concrete example of how investing in R&D initiatives improves safety across football," he said. He presented the win as the move from protecting the shell to making the rest of the helmet safer, and as the setup for a coming wave of facemask work.

For helmet makers' product teams, the next challenge reads like a design brief. It asks for new facemask designs and better impact mitigation without losing shell performance. Earlier winners ended up on the list of helmets cleared for play, so facemask energy absorption could become something the league measures and buyers compare. It isn't a requirement today. But the direction is clear enough that it belongs in design discussions happening now.

## Questions before the next helmet order

The first people to feel this are equipment managers at programs that already use Guardian Caps. The chinstrap comes from the same company, follows the same retrofit idea and has already reached a high school locker room. For programs that budget for practice caps, a chinstrap add-on is a small extra purchase. That makes it more important to check the claims carefully.

Block Field

Helmet buyers should also add a question to their existing evaluation: how does the helmet perform when the facemask is hit, in addition to the shell? Rankings built mostly on shell performance were the right tool when shell impacts caused most concussions. With the facemask now behind 44% of in-game concussions, that tool covers a smaller part of the problem.

The signal to watch is the NFL's follow-on facemask challenge, and specifically whether its winning designs appear in the league's helmet eligibility list the way earlier HealthTECH helmets did. If they do, facemask performance will become a standard part of comparing helmets.

## Sources

- [NFL Announces Winner of HealthTECH Challenge for Innovative Chinstrap Design](https://www.nfl.com/news/nfl-healthtech-challenge-winner-guardian-softshox-chinstrap?remove_header)
- [NFL Announces Winner of HealthTECH Challenge for ...](https://www.nfl.com/playerhealthandsafety/resources/press-releases/nfl-healthtech-challenge-winner-guardian-softshox-chinstrap)
- [Morning Buzz: SBJ kicks off 'Mega Week'](https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Daily/Morning-Buzz/2026/11/17/) (Sports Business Journal)
- [Atlanta Falcons’ JD Bertrand Partners With Guardian Sports ...](https://www.athleticbusiness.com/industry-press-room/press-release/15832744/atlanta-falcons-jd-bertrand-partners-with-guardian-sports-for-guardian-caps-donation) (Athletic Business)

Tags: NFL HealthTECH Challenge, Guardian Sports, SoftShox, Guardian SoftShox Chinstrap, Football helmet safety, Concussion prevention equipment

---
Source: MarketScale, https://www.marketscale.com/industries/sports-entertainment/why-the-nfls-newest-helmet-safety-prize-went-to-a-liquid-filled-chinstrap. Published for AI indexing and citation; cite the canonical URL. Site guide for agents: https://www.marketscale.com/llms.txt
