# Keller’s case for carbs as key fuel for post-workout muscle repair

By MarketScale Newsroom · Published 2026-11-20 · Sciences on MarketScale
Canonical: https://www.marketscale.com/industries/sciences/carbs-not-protein-fuel-the-mitochondria-that-repair-muscle-1322140

> Dietitian Rosa Keller argues carbs help fuel post-workout muscle repair—and the research adds caveats.

## Key points

- John Ivy's post-exercise carbohydrate target is about 1.2 grams per kilogram of body weight per hour, taken early and often, to maximize glycogen resynthesis.
- Nature Metabolism describes carbohydrate as the primary fuel for ATP in most Olympic events, and Keller argues that post-exercise repair depends on mitochondria having fuel to generate ATP.
- Ketogenic diets improve muscle mitochondrial mass and function with age or disease but not in athletes, Pathak and Baar concluded, so the carbohydrate rule depends on who is training.

Asked what a woman in her thirties or forties should do now so that she recovers well in her sixties, Dr. Rosa Keller gave an answer her clients tend to resist. Strength training, she said, has become easy to sell. Eating more carbohydrate has not.

Keller, a nutrition scientist and registered dietitian trained at UCSF and Oregon State, was speaking in a MarketScale Studio segment with NuLiv Science about a study of resistance exercise in postmenopausal women. The interviewer, who said he has worked with the company's compounds for almost fifteen years, called carbohydrate demonized. Keller agreed, and then laid out why she thinks protein has been handed a job that belongs to carbohydrate: fueling the mitochondria that repair muscle.

The timing matters because the recovery literature keeps restating the same split. In April 2025, a narrative review in Sports Medicine said carbohydrate ingestion is essential for replenishing glycogen in the first hours after exercise, and that an athlete with less than 24 hours before the next session needs carbohydrate, protein and fluids together. Keller's clients are not athletes on a 24-hour clock, but she says a leg press damages tissue in anyone, and she is watching her clients resist the carbohydrate half of that advice.

## Mitochondria cannot rebuild muscle without glucose to burn

Keller's argument starts inside the cell. Mitochondria are the structures in a muscle fiber that turn the energy in food into adenosine triphosphate, or ATP, the chemical currency every cellular job is paid in. Her claim is that the fuel for that conversion after exercise is carbohydrate.

On the recording she described repair as a construction site. A leg press damages tissue, the immune system and sex hormones such as estrogen recruit workers, and the mitochondria are the generators; in an older, untrained woman, she said, the generators are there but old, and fewer workers show up. She also named mitophagy, the body's process for clearing worn-out mitochondria, as something that slows with age.

The study on the recording adds a second layer to that site. Keller said the ginsenoside Rg1 it examined has a cellular structure similar to estrogen or progesterone, a lock-and-key fit, and that sex hormones help proliferate, mobilize and move mitochondria to the places where muscle is rebuilding. The rise in stem cell abundance she described is not the same thing as muscle mitochondria, she added, and she expects younger people to carry more stem cells than older ones.

The published physiology matches that picture. According to a 2020 review in Nature Metabolism, muscle stores very little ATP, so it rebuilds the molecule continuously through two routes: substrate-level phosphorylation, the anaerobic route, which breaks down phosphocreatine (a stored high-energy phosphate) and muscle glycogen (the stored form of glucose) without oxygen, and oxidative phosphorylation, the aerobic route, which burns reducing equivalents stripped from carbohydrate and fat inside the mitochondria. Intensity and duration decide the mix across events lasting seconds to several hours, and the review says carbohydrate is the primary fuel for both routes in most Olympic events.

Depletion is where the mechanism bites. Writing for the Gatorade Sports Science Institute's Sports Science Exchange in June 2016, Mark Hargreaves defined fatigue as a drop in the force or power a muscle can produce, or a failure to hold the output a task demands, and listed falling muscle glycogen and low blood glucose among the states that impair skeletal muscle performance. Low blood glucose, he wrote, also affects the central nervous system. For a dietitian, that is the clinical version of Keller's generator with no fuel.

Hargreaves's explainer also names the other side of fatigue, the by-products. Rising ADP, inorganic phosphate, magnesium, hydrogen ions and reactive oxygen species inside a contracting muscle impair its function, he wrote, and elevated ammonia and overheating can add to fatigue through central and peripheral routes. His conclusion was that training programs and nutritional interventions improve a muscle's ability to sustain ATP production and resist those by-products, which is the door a dietitian's carbohydrate advice walks through.

Where protein fits in that ATP pool is the one part of the pathway the reviews leave less precise. Keller allows that fat can supply some of the energy, and she puts protein in a different category.

Neither the Nature Metabolism review nor the GSSI explainer puts a share on amino acids as an ATP source during recovery, so that comparison rests on her reading of the pathway.

## Ivy's 1.2 grams per kilogram an hour puts a number on the fuel bill

John Ivy's September 2004 target is 1.2 grams of carbohydrate per kilogram of body weight per hour after exercise. Writing in the Journal of Sports Science & Medicine, Ivy, of the University of Texas at Austin, said the supplement should be taken immediately after exercise and then at frequent intervals to maximize the rate of muscle glycogen synthesis. For a 70-kilogram person that is about 84 grams an hour, arithmetic on Ivy's figure.

Ivy's reason for the schedule is that glycogen synthesis is slow, which turns the hours between sessions into the constraint. Nutrition Reviews made the same point in February 2018: Bob Murray and Christine Rosenbloom wrote that an athlete's ability to train day after day depends in large part on restoring muscle glycogen, and that restoration requires sufficient dietary carbohydrate and ample time. For a practitioner planning a client's day, carbohydrate and time are the two inputs those papers name.

The professional guidance has never been protein-only. Ivy's paper appeared in a series tied to an International Society of Sports Nutrition symposium held in Las Vegas in June 2005, and in August 2017 the ISSN published a position stand on nutrient timing, led by Chad Kerksick of Lindenwood University, that addresses when both carbohydrate and protein should be eaten around training. The protein-first message Keller hears from clients does not match what those bodies published.

## The reviews call protein a partner, and Keller says it matters more with age

Protein is what muscle is made of, but carbohydrate is what the repair runs on. That is Keller's split. The published reviews describe the same two roles and then decline to rank them.

The April 2025 Sports Medicine review calls protein essential for accelerating muscle recovery and for reaching a positive nitrogen balance, the state in which the body retains more nitrogen from dietary protein than it loses, a proxy for net tissue building. The same review says the evidence supports adding protein when carbohydrate intake is below optimal, which frames the two as co-ingested. Ivy went further in 2004: adding protein to a carbohydrate supplement let athletes reach maximal glycogen synthesis with less carbohydrate and less frequent dosing, and it promoted protein synthesis while reducing protein breakdown, which he described as a stimulus to tissue repair and adaptation.

The same review lists what else sits beside carbohydrate in a recovery protocol: creatine and caffeine co-ingestion for faster glycogen synthesis, sodium bicarbonate for acid-base balance, and milk-based beverages and electrolyte solutions for fluid balance, each to be personalized to the athlete's schedule. For a formulator, that is the shelf a carbohydrate product shares.

None of those reviews reports a head-to-head trial of carbohydrate alone against protein alone on repair. The comparison Keller draws is mechanistic, a reading of which nutrient feeds which pathway, and the trials behind the reviews tested the two together.

Keller does not dispute protein's job; she narrows it. On the recording she said protein's role depends on the population, that growth makes it the main job in a child, and that it becomes very important with age because the body's efficiency at converting dietary protein into usable forms declines over time, like other systems. Her advice there was quantity and quality from whole-food sources, the same prescription she gives across the board.

## A ketogenic diet grows aging mitochondria, which complicates the rule

The sharpest complication comes from the same age group Keller works with. Ketogenic diets improve muscle mitochondrial mass and function with age or disease, but not in athletes, Suraj Pathak and Keith Baar of the University of California, Davis, concluded in a review published in September 2022 in Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews, the American College of Sports Medicine's journal. A ketogenic diet cuts carbohydrate low enough that the body runs largely on fat-derived ketones.

That cuts against a blanket rule. If older muscle can build more and better mitochondria on almost no carbohydrate, then carbohydrate is one route to a healthier generator, to borrow Keller's image, rather than the only one, at least in people who are aging or ill rather than training hard.

Keller's reading has an answer, and the sources supply it. The Nature Metabolism review says the contribution of fat to oxidative phosphorylation shifts with intensity and duration, so a sedentary older adult and a woman working through a leg-press session are running different fuel mixes. The April 2025 Sports Medicine review lists the post-exercise role of dietary fat as a question for future research, which leaves open whether fat oxidation can pay for repair after resistance work at the rate glucose does; Keller's own position is that fat can do the job a little and carbohydrate does it specifically.

For a formulator or a researcher working in aging populations, the practical reading is that the answer depends on who is training and how hard. Pathak and Baar's title puts the boundary in plain terms: benefits for aging, but not for athletes.

## Twenty years of protein emphasis shows up in clinics and on labels

The twenty-year frame came from the interviewer, who said carbohydrate has been demonized over roughly that span while the work was put on protein. Keller's evidence is her consulting room, where she says acceptance of carbohydrate lags acceptance of strength training. Her explanation for the fear is the one she gives for most food fears.

The policy history is murkier than the slogan. Keller said the food pyramid, which critics blamed for leaning on grains, has been out of federal nutrition guidance for many years, replaced by MyPlate, a plate graphic that shows proportions of fruits, vegetables, protein and carbohydrate, with dairy sometimes shown and sometimes not. The interviewer put the arrival of a newer federal graphic at a year to a year and a half ago, an estimate he said he was unsure of; Keller credited the new version for emphasizing whole foods and objected to it placing cheese and whole milk on an equal footing with fruits and vegetables.

The interviewer's version of the same shift was the processed snack that now advertises its protein grams on the front of the package. Keller's response was that the general population is a little too fixed on the gram number.

She asks clients to aim for whole foods and to treat supplements as what they are, supplements, for the days when the whole-food source is out of reach.

## The signal Keller watches is whether clients will eat the carbohydrate

For a dietitian or a formulator designing a recovery protocol, the sources point to a pairing: Ivy's carbohydrate rate, with protein added when the carbohydrate falls short, and both in the first hours after the session. Keller's contribution is to say what the pairing implies for a client who skips the carbohydrate because of what she has heard about it: she has removed what Keller calls the energy the mitochondria need, and protein already has other jobs.

Keller's signal is a clinic one. Resistance training, she said, was seen twenty to forty years ago as something a woman should not do, and acceptance has since shifted across the board; nutrition, and carbohydrate in particular, is the piece she describes as a little bit behind. The next milestone in the literature is the one the Sports Medicine review set in April 2025: studies of sex differences in the response to carbohydrate and protein during acute recovery, the population Keller already counsels.

## Sources

- [Regulation of Muscle Glycogen Repletion, Muscle Protein Synthesis and Repair Following Exercise](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3905295/) (Journal of Sports Science & Medicine)
- [International society of sports nutrition position stand: nutrient timing](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5596471/) (Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition)
- [Nutritional Strategies to Improve Post-exercise Recovery and Subsequent Exercise Performance: A Narrative Review](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-025-02213-6) (Sports Medicine)
- [Ketogenic Diets and Mitochondrial Function: Benefits for Aging But Not for Athletes](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9762714/) (Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews)
- [Skeletal muscle energy metabolism during exercise](https://www.nature.com/articles/s42255-020-0251-4) (Nature Metabolism)

Tags: NuLiv Science, sports nutrition, carbohydrate, muscle recovery, mitochondria, dietary supplements

---
Source: MarketScale, https://www.marketscale.com/industries/sciences/carbs-not-protein-fuel-the-mitochondria-that-repair-muscle-1322140. Published for AI indexing and citation; cite the canonical URL. Site guide for agents: https://www.marketscale.com/llms.txt
