# Why Leadership Without Humanity Is Failing Today’s Workplace

By Vince Holland · Published 2026-03-24 · Updated 2026-05-19 · Retail on MarketScale
Canonical: https://www.marketscale.com/industries/retail/why-leadership-without-humanity-is-failing-todays-workplace
Creator hub: Straight Outta Crumpton

> As the world faces historic labor shortages, an increase in burnout, and record-high turnover, organizations are confronting a leadership reckoning. In May 2024, Gallup found that more than 50 percent of U.S. employees were actively searching for new jobs or watching for openings. Taken together, these trends signal a clear and growing breakdown in…

## Key points

- Promoting employees based solely on technical skills often creates managers who can supervise tasks but struggle to coach, develop, or truly lead people.
- Fear-based leadership may drive short-term compliance but erodes long-term engagement, loyalty, and team performance.
- Authentic leadership requires balancing compassion with accountability — leaders must 'love people and show the way' to build healthy, high-performing cultures.

Block Field

As the world faces historic labor shortages, an increase in burnout, and record-high turnover, organizations are confronting a leadership reckoning. In May 2024, Gallup found that more than [50 percent of U.S. employees were actively searching for new jobs or watching for openings](https://www.gallup.com/workplace/650174/employee-retention-depends-getting-recognition-right.aspx). Taken together, these trends signal a clear and growing breakdown in how people are being led.

So, what happens when leadership loses its human core, and how can organizations restore it before people think of walking out the door?

On this episode of [*Straight Outta Crumpton*](https://marketscale.com/shows/straight-outta-crumpton/), host [Greg Crumpton](https://www.linkedin.com/in/crumptonskilledtrades/) welcomes thinker and speaker [Steve Thomas](https://www.stevejthomas.com/about.html) for a candid conversation on what Thomas calls “the foolishness of leadership” — a pattern of managing processes while forgetting the human element behind them. Together, they explore how organizations unintentionally dehumanize teams, why traditional promotion models fail, and what authentic leadership looks like in today’s changing workforce.

**Key takeaways…**

- Why leadership is about people, not positions. Promoting individuals based solely on technical expertise often creates managers who can supervise but cannot truly lead, coach, or develop others.
- The modern workforce requires psychological safety and emotional intelligence. Research shows that fear-based leadership may produce short-term compliance, but eventually [damages long-term engagement, loyalty, and growth](https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3387/14/9/225).
- Thomas explains that leaders have to “love people and show the way,” and be able to balance compassion with clarity and accountability to build healthy, high-performing teams.

Steve Thomas is a nationally recognized speaker, consultant, and founder of [The Scooch Project](https://www.thescoochproject.com/), an organization dedicated to helping individuals and companies grow in leadership and life. With decades of experience across industries including skilled trades, construction, and manufacturing, he is known for a direct, human-centered approach to leadership development. He is also the creator of Scooch Leadership Labs—hands-on leadership intensives hosted across the United States—and the host of the *Budge* podcast, where he explores practical ways to build healthier cultures and leaders.

*Article written by MarketScale.*

Tags: emotional intelligence, Greg Crumpton, human-centered leadership, leadership development, Steve Thomas, Straight Outta Crumpton, The Scooch Project, workplace culture

---
Source: MarketScale, https://www.marketscale.com/industries/retail/why-leadership-without-humanity-is-failing-todays-workplace. Published for AI indexing and citation; cite the canonical URL. Site guide for agents: https://www.marketscale.com/llms.txt